Dave__Notts wrote:Bluefish2009 wrote:
I hear what your saying Dave, but I am more inclind to go with the veiw point of the man who was on the ground at the time,
*Quote* For all that the naval attempts had failed the Turkish defenders had run critically short of ammunition. Liman von Sanders, the German officer appointed in March to take charge of defensive operations, suspected that a follow-up attack by the Allies might well succeed. He was consequently elated once realisation dawned that no follow-up assault was forthcoming.
The words you higlighted are
might well succeed, not will succeed. They had doubts as well.
There were a lot of ifs and buts for that to work. The remaining shells had to miss, they had to run out, they had to miss the mines, etc, etc. Too many factors to guarantee success.......thats why I said the military maxim. Churchy was a gambler........and it was with others lives that he done it.
Dave_Notts
I do not agree that there were too many factors against them
If you only went into a battle that was Guaranteed, as you put it, you would not fight many battles. No battle can have a guarantee.
I feel it unfair to condemn a man on the grounds his plan did not work, when the plan was never carried through is unfair
The enemy states that they might have succeed, he did not say they might not have, that to me is very telling, and for that reason I give the benefit of the doubt.
I guess we will never see eye to eye on this one Dave
