Quote by freckledbird
For God's sake just leave it, Ukman. The mods do a job (might be different to the mod job you do, but that IS on a different site) and you've agreed to the terms of the site in order to be a member. If you don't like it, just leave. Complaining about rules you've accepted won't get you anywhere. Unless you are shown the door for going on about it.
Well I personally like what he is saying and can relate to a lot of it. I think this sort of debate is healthy and Sarge said the mods were following it. If you are not interested don't read this one thread, rather than lambasting those who have put time and effort into a post. Sorry but it is obvious that this is important to some people and negative comments have pushed some of it into PM so now I (as a regular and interested user) can't follow it as you didn't want to have to ignore it
If you are not interested please don't waste your time reading my post, or mine simply complaining I made it. If you want to argue the points I would be happy to talk about them, but Sarge asked for comment so I am providing it.
As a member for over a year I have seen the cafe go up... and down... now I respect the mods immensly, know a few of them personally, and think they have a tough job. I know this is Marks site, I know it is all done on a voluntary basis, and I know the AUP means you can lock, edit, delete or whatever any post. Oh yes and we can all leave if we don't like it as has been said... but I thought locking was to stop members leaving due to 'crap' posts not push them out the door for not liking it and saying so?
Ok I sound like I having a dig but this is really letting off steam, I have been blasted for wanting to put points on the other how we do things type thread on social meets. I have seen long term members and friends getting upset with the site, and newbes leave to. They are not all flouncers, and some of them brought good things to us here.
So much for moaning, what would I do? Well not lock anything, there is nothing more annoying than not being able to reply to a thread, if it an idiot one it will get hijacked, or ignored. This sorts people out more than a lock as they see the lack of reaction (or incur the wrath of to cafe) and it gets them no pleasure. Locking in some ways makes em feel noticed.
As for 'we done this to death!!' so what? Leave it, maybe it is ripe for another visit or some new people (they do keep joining) will want to put their point of view and this is all for the good. Adding to an old post I find worse, I don't have time to read through 15 pages of an old post to find the 5 new posts at the end. I often have to speed read the cafe, anything over 5 or so pages will normally be skipped, so old threads at 20 pages about shaving are no use to me. Put a link in to the old thread yes, this adds depth for those with time to read it but let it run. Sod the regulars a little here, if you not interested in shaving debate don't read it, let the new people have their say though...
What about a serial poster? 20 threads a day of crap? Ok this is a serious problem and the mods would need to dive in with the individual, we there I think are talking deleting threads raised by them and maybe bans. I have seen this a few times and respect the mods for acting (although others didn't) However the same apprach to all newbee threads and anything considered 'crap' is too far IMHO. Let the threads die on there own, surely we can learn to ignore what we don't want to read?
At the end of the day sticking to the AUP saves the mods work as if it not in the AUP it will get left. Now if as was suggested we end up with a horseriding group using us all the time, then eventually the cafe would get the hump and a thread would be started for an open debate on it. If that lead us to feel this should be taken away from the cafe then there you go, open, democratic, and we get to a solution the mods can act on without having to do all the soul searching themselves.
