Does the 50p top tax rate damage the UK economy ?

Does the 50p top tax rate damage the UK economy

20 Sep 2011

seems just like me that peeple have there opinions as to why doctors are leeving the nhs but seems that there is no evidence of many things.
" Unions said the issue was linked to high workloads, but the government said there was no evidence of this."
so even the unions say what reesons are but the government say there is no evidence ether, so i am not alone here in not being able to supply evidence as it seems a bit of a sticky subject.
or another example of one person saying a reeson and another stating no evidence.
" Dr Shree Datta, chairman of the BMA's junior doctors committee, said: "Understaffing makes our work much more intense and does not go unnoticed by our patients."
But a Department of Health spokeswoman said there was no evidence of this."
seems plenty of opinions but not a lot of evidence and that is the same for money reesons as well. it seems that studys into this have not been looked into.

20 Sep 2011

Quote by starlightcouple
that of course is your right to think that way. many other peeple look at life in a differant way to you.
unfortunatly long gone are the days when you could live off the land and lead a nice normal life. you have a home i presume and go to the shops for food, so money is an important part of your life. other peeple take that one step further and opt to buy nice clothes or a nice car through usually hard work.
i cannot see why you are so against this. obviusly it is your political persuasions which i am sorry do not hold court for the vast majority of the uk residents. thankfully there is no political party either that holds those views. certainly not one with any chance of ever getting into power democratically.

I have a home ,a car and some very nice clothes .... the point is, money is not important , I enjoy what it can buy, but I have no interest in money or it's acquisition

20 Sep 2011

Quote by starlightcouple
but after some extensive visits to my local nhs hospital over the last 3 yeers, i can assure you that british doctors are in very short supply.

Are you sure?
Dave_Notts

20 Sep 2011

Quote by starlightcouple

seems just like me that peeple have there opinions as to why doctors are leeving the nhs but seems that there is no evidence of many things.
" Unions said the issue was linked to high workloads, but the government said there was no evidence of this."
so even the unions say what reesons are but the government say there is no evidence ether, so i am not alone here in not being able to supply evidence as it seems a bit of a sticky subject.
or another example of one person saying a reeson and another stating no evidence.
" Dr Shree Datta, chairman of the BMA's junior doctors committee, said: "Understaffing makes our work much more intense and does not go unnoticed by our patients."
But a Department of Health spokeswoman said there was no evidence of this."
seems plenty of opinions but not a lot of evidence and that is the same for money reesons as well. it seems that studys into this have not been looked into.

And it seems to me that non of the reasons that ARE given would be improved by reducing the tax take and therefore the availability of funding ... It seems that the polar opposite is in fact the case

20 Sep 2011

Quote by Dave__Notts
but after some extensive visits to my local nhs hospital over the last 3 yeers, i can assure you that british doctors are in very short supply.

Are you sure?
Dave_Notts
i stated cleerly IN MY LOCAL HOSPITAL.
other hospitals could well tell another story.

20 Sep 2011

Quote by starlightcouple
but after some extensive visits to my local nhs hospital over the last 3 yeers, i can assure you that british doctors are in very short supply.

Are you sure?
Dave_Notts
i stated cleerly IN MY LOCAL HOSPITAL.
other hospitals could well tell another story.
You clearly stated that British Doctors are in short supply after using your local hospital as a yard stick after your extensive visits. The link shows you are wrong that British doctors are in short supply
Your other statement of "your friend" earns twice as much in Australia than the UK is debateable as well. Looking at the NHS banding for midwifery and the Australian equivalent then the wages are comparable.
Dave_Notts

20 Sep 2011

Problem with internet forums like this, as opposed to chatting in the pub with mates of a kindred spirit, is that you end up having debates with people who have have a polar opposite political and ideological opinion.
In real life I would not waste my breath engaging moaning, whining, losers who won't take responsibility for their own lives but i seem to get engaged in debates with people like that on here. Review of motives methinks.

21 Sep 2011

Quote by Too Hot
Problem with internet forums like this, as opposed to chatting in the pub with mates of a kindred spirit, is that you end up having debates with people who have have a polar opposite political and ideological opinion.
In real life I would not waste my breath engaging moaning, whining, losers who won't take responsibility for their own lives but i seem to get engaged in debates with people like that on here. Review of motives methinks.

The problem with chatting down the pub with mates is you never learn anything .. you just have your misconceptions confirmed.
I take it from the above post that rather than attempt to answer any opposing points,you're just going to spit your dummy out and stomp off.
These moaning,whining losers then ??? who are they ?? care to offer some evidence for your assertion that they refuse to take responsibility ??

21 Sep 2011

Quote by Staggerlee_BB
The problem with chatting down the pub with mates is you never learn anything .. you just have your misconceptions confirmed.

is that why you popped back here? :grin::grin:
bolt