Join the most popular community of UK swingers now
Login

France & Greece say - "No more austerity!"

last reply
39 replies
1.7k views
0 watchers
0 likes
Interesting times ahead as both France and Greece give austerity a poke in the eye. Is this the end for Greece in the Euro? Is this France saying Au Revoir to the Euro by choice?
Is there an alternative to austerity? Is it all about spending your way out of a crisis and just printing more money?
Nope there is no real alternative to austerity. The bottom line is somebody is going to be at the shitty end of the stick.
The predictions for Greece if it drops out of the Euro aren't great, civil war, military junta's etc. Not so sure what will happen in France, but at least one of the ratings agencies has dropped the French sovereign debt rating down.
The fundamental problem seems to be that there is no 'lender of last resort' for the Euro. It is illegal for the ECB to undertake 'quantitative easing' (print money, buy bonds back and thereby decrease the yield on government debt) as happened here and in the US. This would exchange public sector debt for inflation.
Quantitative easing is a fancy term for what governments have been doing for years when faced with a deep hole in finances. As happens the 'hit' is then taken by the countries savers (usually pensioners) so the austerity just moves to a different group.
I would guess it can only really end one of two ways, either the Eurozone allows QE by the ECB, or countries will drop out of the Euro. The election results tend to suggest the other alternative reducing government spending is unacceptable to at least Greece and France.
It's interesting now to see world leaders cosying up to François Hollande in order to persuade him not to upset the apple cart.
DC, the British PM, particularly so considering that he effectively snubbed him when he visited London during the Presidential campaign and left it to "two 'eds are better than one" Miliband to provide him his morning coffee and croissant. Now, he's all over him like a cheap suit as his worst fears may be about to be realised - that there may after all be something in what the Labour party have been saying about austerity measures being counter-productive.
The emergence of Mme Marine Le Pen slagging off both Sarkozy and Hollande both before the run off and moments after Hollande was declared the President Elect is interesting and serves to support the view that the extreme right (as in Greece) are gaining ground and the centre right are losing it.
One of Hollande's stated policy decisions will be to remove French troops from Afghanistan this year (hence the early invitation to visit the White House and Camp David later in the year). Obama is himself a socialist President (in all but name) and fears that the USA will be left holding the baby. Well, too right that it should; it caused most of the world order problems anyway!
If Hollande pulls it off, he could probably fund one of his other pledges - to increase the number of teachers across France without resorting to increased lending.
Mme Aubrey, the leader of his party PS, is likely to be appointed Prime Minister and she is of course the daughter of the architect of the Euro, Jacques Delors. Whilst a significant number of les français prefer a return to the Franc as a currency, it is extremely unlikely to happen under Hollande's stewardship of the Élysée Palace and with Aubrey occupying the Hôtel Matignon and after 17 years in the wilderness and Mme Le Pen snapping at his heels, he will be wanting to buck the right wing prophesy that you can't spend your way out of a crisis. He will want to do it by screwing the Yanks and making significant savings on military interventions.
This time, it could possibly be Hollande who has his fingers clutching DC's wallet, not the other way round following the UK/Franco accord signed by Sarkozy.
Watch this space...
Quote by GnV
DC, the British PM, particularly so considering that he effectively snubbed him when he visited London during the Presidential campaign and left it to "two 'eds are better than one" Miliband to provide him his morning coffee and croissant.

maybe it is a similar snub to the one DC endured dunno
maybe GNV it is the british way of snubbing peeple lol
just a thought flipa
Quote by starlightcouple

DC, the British PM, particularly so considering that he effectively snubbed him when he visited London during the Presidential campaign and left it to "two 'eds are better than one" Miliband to provide him his morning coffee and croissant.

maybe it is a similar snub to the one DC endured dunno
maybe GNV it is the british way of snubbing peeple lol
just a thought flipa
Shades of Déjà vu come to mind here star... there was no snub by M. Sarkozy - except in the minds of those whose closely follow the escapades of the Bland Broadcasting Corporation, second only to readers of The Daily Wail
But having had personal experience of the bad treatment doled out to our French cousins by the ignorant snivelling British, I can see where you're coming from :grin:
Quote by GnV
But having had personal experience of the bad treatment doled out to our French cousins by the ignorant snivelling British, I can see where you're coming from :grin:

awwww GNV :violin:
when we went to central france about 6 years ago, my experience is it was the frenchos who were very ignorant. i dont know if the french were snivelling as well, as we were not there long enough to form a proper opinion. lol
still GNV i bet you still have your ignorant snivelling british passport :doh::rascal:
Quote by starlightcouple

But having had personal experience of the bad treatment doled out to our French cousins by the ignorant snivelling British, I can see where you're coming from :grin:

awwww GNV :violin:
when we went to central france about 6 years ago, my experience is it was the frenchos who were very ignorant. i dont know if the french were snivelling as well, as we were not there long enough to form a proper opinion. lol
still GNV i bet you still have your ignorant snivelling british passport :doh::rascal:
The difference here star is that I am British... (and yes, I still have a British Passport) I just happened to be driving a French car (my car) on British soil and was subjected to the kind of vitriol I know from first hand emanates from a supposed multi-cultural but two faced society.
In the case of a Brit abroad - no matter where they are, it is the British arrogance that usually shines through in the form of a demand that everyone, even in their own home country, should address Brits abroad in English. I see it almost daily here in SW France where British ex-pats refuse to embrace the French way of life and their language when they come here to live.
sorry GNV but in many cases you cannot have your cake and eat it as well, without paying a price.
it was not a guess about the passport as i kinds gathered that would be the case. give up the british nationality GNV and become a proper frencho. viva la france rolleyes
Quote by starlightcouple
sorry GNV but in many cases you cannot have your cake and eat it as well, without paying a price.
it was not a guess about the passport as i kinds gathered that would be the case. give up the british nationality GNV and become a proper frencho. viva la france rolleyes

Would do so tomorrow star... but the French are more circumspect about who they will allow to have French citizenship.
I have to learn more of their language first, to the extent of a final year Bac student.
Pity some other countries don't have the same standard...
Quote by GnV
I have to learn more of their language first, to the extent of a final year Bac student.
Pity some other countries don't have the same standard...

yes it should be harder to get into some countries, but is it easy to get into the uk then? rotflmao:rotflmao::rotflmao:
i think they let all and sundry in GNV and maybe that is why some brits are called ignorant and snivelling. over here you cannot tell who is british and who is not, maybe you was dealing with a frencho who was living in the uk when you had your bad experience GNV flipa
Quote by starlightcouple
maybe you was dealing with a frencho who was living in the uk when you had your bad experience GNV flipa

Polish actually, I recall....
Quote by GnV
maybe you was dealing with a frencho who was living in the uk when you had your bad experience GNV flipa

Polish actually, I recall....
polish peeple working in the uk GNV?
you been reading to many frencho socialist newspapers. wink
i think we may have one or two here. worship
seems to a Brit abroad that the Poles are the only ones who work in the UK :grin:
austerity for whom ? there is no austerity for bankers. no austerity for c.e.o.'s, no austerity for m.p.'s no austerity for royalty ? no alternative ? yes there is. you who created the problem, keep the phucker instead of passing it on to us. you who made bad bets keep the returns or lack of and you suffer austerity. the losses of banks and financial institutions have been passed on to us the taxpayers worldwide by salivating excuses for elected representatives of the people. you've got money for wars to annex and steal killing hundreds of thousands but none for bread.
repudiate the debt, it was created by fraud !
i'm paying more in tax and i want it spending on services and infrastructure not wars of agression and annexation to steal natural resources and still charge me a litre for fuel ! i dont want to send western democracy (joke) and freedom to bomb foreign lands and end up in poverty.
Quote by gulsonroad30664
austerity for whom ? there is no austerity for bankers. no austerity for c.e.o.'s, no austerity for m.p.'s no austerity for royalty ? no alternative ? yes there is. you who created the problem, keep the phucker instead of passing it on to us. you who made bad bets keep the returns or lack of and you suffer austerity. the losses of banks and financial institutions have been passed on to us the taxpayers worldwide by salivating excuses for elected representatives of the people. you've got money for wars to annex and steal killing hundreds of thousands but none for bread.
repudiate the debt, it was created by fraud !
i'm paying more in tax and i want it spending on services and infrastructure not wars of agression and annexation to steal natural resources and still charge me a litre for fuel ! i dont want to send western democracy (joke) and freedom to bomb foreign lands and end up in poverty.

MP 's salaries have been frozen for this year at just over £ 65 K. According to a previous post you made, you earn £120K per annum. So if there is no austerity for MP's then I guess there must be none for you Gulson.
Based on your comments GNV, I would guess the French are going to try and put pressure on the Eurozone to loosen the 'rules' regarding the ECB. In fact the news on the BBC seems to suggest this is pretty much what the French are doing.
It does look like Greece is going to be leaving the Euro, assuming that they can form any government, and don't just get taken over by the military.
This still doesn't get rid of Austerity, as I mentioned above, somebody will pay. The Greeks really badly I suspect.
Interesting if slightly incoherent rant Gulson smile. It would be lovely to declare the income of various bankers and MP's the 'proceeds of crime'. Then round them up, ideally with the retail rioters from last summer, and drop them on a small currently uninhabited island. They could then just get on with it outside the rest of society.
However I don't think that savings on defense spending are going to be sufficient to address the UK's deficit. If you look a good half to two thirds of expenditure goes on benefits, and health care. Also being (overly) charitable to the bankers the costs of the various bailouts are small compared to the rest of government expenditure.
As to your suggestion that 'Western Democracy' is a joke, you might like to think on the fact that you can make exactly that statement without reprisals?
Quote by Robert400andKay
Based on your comments GNV, I would guess the French are going to try and put pressure on the Eurozone to loosen the 'rules' regarding the ECB. In fact the news on the BBC seems to suggest this is pretty much what the French are doing.

I doubt the ECB would relax their lending rules. How this fits in with the fact that France has been borrowing for over 40 years, I'm not sure but there must be some way round it.
So far as the German Chancellor is concerned, the austerity pact is non negotiable but I believe that M. le président élu François Hollande who will be visiting the Chancellor the day after his inauguration next week will try to persuade her to add growth measures to the accord. If she doesn't it might spell the end of it since Ireland may well vote against in their up and coming referendum. Perhaps M. Hollande has in mind to overstep the ECB rules by funding 'growth' as opposed to debt?
If François Hollande doesn't stand by his word at such an early stage in his tenure of the presidency (much like Sarkozy didn't) the honeymoon will soon be over much before it has begun. He will be under immense pressure to dump his very un-European stance on austerity by the Germans but there are many more who will be egging him onwards (not least of which the Labour Party UK) to destabilise the remaining European centre right administrations.
Angela Merkel is also due for re-election soon so she is also walking a tight rope as her fallibility emerges and the German electorate gain confidence in seeking alternatives.
The French may well be looking to the 'European Financial Stability Facility', which still seems to be a part of the ECB.....

Even german people joining in..and saying enough is enough !!!
France enters a new era tomorrow with François Hollande sworn in as the first socialist president for nearly two decades tomorrow.
German socialists just like supporters of the British Labour Party will be keeping a very close eye on how he faires on Wednesday when he meets Angela Merkal. Merkal will be squirming like a fish on a hook to hold on to the centre right austerity mantra but I somehow think that the rot is already set in. German's too want change and her position is in doubt in their forthcoming elections.
The GBP/EUR is reflecting the discontent in the money markets as Greece comes closer to leaving the Euro.
Quote by GnV
Mme Aubrey, the leader of his party PS, is likely to be appointed Prime Minister and she is of course the daughter of the architect of the Euro, Jacques Delors.

Well, it seems I got that wrong.
Long time friend, ally and Hollande collaborator, Jean-Marc Ayrault is the new Prime Minister and as it emerges that there were many internal disagreements in the PS prior to the election, Mme Aubrey seems set to be be isolated and will not join the Government.
François Hollande does seem to be his own man after all.
Well, well, well.
Alastair Darling confronts the Chancellor in the House today and gorgeous George freely admits that there must be growth with austerity. Quite a change on his previous language.
The PM in Manchester also sends the same message.
Could this possibly be something to do with the election of François Hollande?
France leading the revolution in Europe!
Vive la France!!
Vive le Président 7éme de la 5éme République Français!
I think the meaning of austerity has become somewhat clouded in the confusion of the times.
Lets reduce a country to a person.
Person suddenly realises he has spent what he has not got, is living beyond his means and is massively in debt - what to do?
Austerity means that he tightens his belt to spend less and work harder to bring more in (growth). Austerity = save money and work harder to bring money in.
Somehow the work harder bit has become lost in the confusion.
I would suggest watching The Great Euro Crash on catch up for those that didn't see it on BBC2 tonight at 9 pm.
Robert Peston gives a great insight into what went wrong and the stark choices facing the EC.
Quote by Too Hot
I think the meaning of austerity has become somewhat clouded in the confusion of the times.
Lets reduce a country to a person.
Person suddenly realises he has spent what he has not got, is living beyond his means and is massively in debt - what to do?
Austerity means that he tightens his belt to spend less and work harder to bring more in (growth). Austerity = save money and work harder to bring money in.
Somehow the work harder bit has become lost in the confusion.

Too simplistic Too Hot.
In order to work harder, he might have to borrow more to be able to pay his way to work... Speculate to accumulate.
Quote by Max777
I would suggest watching The Great Euro Crash on catch up for those that didn't see it on BBC2 tonight at 9 pm.
Robert Peston gives a great insight into what went wrong and the stark choices facing the EC.

yep i watched it last night :eeek:
scary shit i think the end is nigh for the euro blink
Quote by GnV
I think the meaning of austerity has become somewhat clouded in the confusion of the times.
Lets reduce a country to a person.
Person suddenly realises he has spent what he has not got, is living beyond his means and is massively in debt - what to do?
Austerity means that he tightens his belt to spend less and work harder to bring more in (growth). Austerity = save money and work harder to bring money in.
Somehow the work harder bit has become lost in the confusion.

Too simplistic Too Hot.
In order to work harder, he might have to borrow more to be able to pay his way to work... Speculate to accumulate.
way to simplistic
what about Austerity = worked hard all my life, paid into a pension, which I got told would look after me when I retire. Now made redundant and due to the banking crisis the persion is slowly becoming worthless !!
or Austerity = oh no that my bonus down from 3 million to 1 million.
if want to take it down to a personal level...how about you are in debt, and so don't eat for a month, don't have heating on etc.....extreme yes....but pays debt off. however you die of starvation and hyperthermia in process. Or you can spread the cost over 6 monthes and still eat ( just not quite as much) and have heating ( just not quite so high ) on. In six monthes you are still alive.
Fact is as I have been saying all along it takes some growth and stimulus to generate the income we need to pay off the debt. No one is saying spend, spend, spend. What we are saying is don't try to pay the bill off, in one go and stave in the process.....spread the debt over a longer period, and therefore have some money left to eat with.
Quote by deancannock
way to simplistic
what about Austerity = worked hard all my life, paid into a pension, which I got told would look after me when I retire. Now made redundant and due to the banking crisis the persion is slowly becoming worthless !!
or Austerity = oh no that my bonus down from 3 million to 1 million.
if want to take it down to a personal level...how about you are in debt, and so don't eat for a month, don't have heating on etc.....extreme yes....but pays debt off. however you die of starvation and hyperthermia in process. Or you can spread the cost over 6 monthes and still eat ( just not quite as much) and have heating ( just not quite so high ) on. In six monthes you are still alive.
Fact is as I have been saying all along it takes some growth and stimulus to generate the income we need to pay off the debt. No one is saying spend, spend, spend. What we are saying is don't try to pay the bill off, in one go and stave in the process.....spread the debt over a longer period, and therefore have some money left to eat with.

In the case of Greece, I think I read somewhere that the longer period amounts to 700 years....
But I see where you are coming from dean :thumbup:
watching the program last night i think the thing that stuck in my mind was the fact that most countries falsified accounts to gain entry to the euro with the added fact that most of Europe's banks are trading insolvent ............looks for impending doom emoticon