Join the most popular community of UK swingers now
Login

Compensation Claims

last reply
21 replies
1.2k views
0 watchers
0 likes

I read this in my local paper and I'm still not sure how I feel about it! One the one hand sexual harrassment, whether it be against a male or female, is not something I stomach and I agree should be challenged. However, I wonder if people have also forgotten the adage of "sticks and stones".
On the other hand, how can her claim be worth The article above states that it is a percentage of the banks gross turnover, but I fail to see how that is directly related to the woman's claim.
Loss of earnings, distress, that I get but she would never have earned that much working in the position she was in and in the geographical area!
The compensation culture we have now seems to bear little relation to actual claims in relation to loss of earnings, distress, expenses etc. Surely these people realise that excessive claims just impact further down the line.
I don't suppose for one minute this woman is believing that she will get in the current economic climate and if she does I hope there will be outrage!
Are we just too greedy or should we be entitled to "go for broke" in compensation claims?
I was at the wrong end of a medical mishap which has caused me grief, quite a bit of it. What concerned me is that within two days of coming out of 6 weeks in ICU I had an ambulance chasing representative of a medical negligence specialist sitting on the end of my bed in HDU!! I'm a bit odd about all this blame culture and I know no one tried to kill me in hospital quite the reverse and I told the leeching bastard to f*ck off. So I say that this compensation stuff should be dealt with by a government department with guidelnes on how and if payments should be made. Not the courts unless there is a need for taking it there. Good sense should prevail.
This is very much like the chap who sued for £300,000 for slipping on a grape. Made a great story and everyone had a moan about it.......but then the papers failed to report that the action failed in court.
The thing I love about this country is that if anybody injures you in anyway then you can sue them for damages. If it is proved that they have, then they rightly have to give you compensation. What this does do is open it up for abuse. This is what is widely reported as the "norm" and people get hot under the collar about it. Claims are dropping in this country and even the insurance companies admit we do not have a claims culture............but that doesn't sell papers.
What do I feel about this woman making a claim? As far as I am concerned, she has every right to under our laws..........so she should if she believes she has been injured in any way. Is the money at the right level? I think it should be on an individual basis and left up to the courts to decide. Having a sliding scale set in stone will never cover all eventualities. Like the case of the Judge who told a couple to be more careful next time. They fell off a plastic chair and sued P&O for £3000. The judge gave them £150 and told them to be more careful as accidents happen......... lol He is my kind of Judge
Dave_Notts
Well who wants to bet she won't get a LARGE bunce of money?
The courts and society are I am afraid to say, terrified of being labelled a racist in anyway.
She as usual is playing the race card. It is the best card in the pack. Check the Met officer, you know that one that was second in command. The highest ranking Asian officer, yet he still screamed racism.
Sorry it does not wash with me one bit. Had she of been a white Christian woman, they would have laughed that ammount out of sight. But lets be honest here, from Governments, to politicians to teachers and everyone else, to be called a racist, even though no evidence could be there, is nowadays the worst thing that can happen.
No doubt the bank will settle out of court, just like they did with those other two women recently. Funnily enough they both said the same thing this woman has said. £16 million quid? A soldier would be lucky if he got a hundred grand for losing both his legs.....it is so crazy but then again we have brought this crap on ourselves. mad
That's an obscene amount of money for that type of compensation. A friend of mine spent 11 years fighting for compensation when he was knocked off his motorbike by a driver pulling out from a side road without checking the road properly. Mate lost the use of his arm and leg, suffered the most dreadful road rash ( as in skin and muscle scraped off down to the bone in some places ) and he hasn't been able to work or support his family since.
After 11 years he was finally awarded the equivalent of his lost earnings from the time of the accident to the time he would have retired ( which would have by now only been 7 years away ) What he was given could never make up for the pain and anguish he and his family have been through over the years, the PTSD he has suffered since the accident and his feelings of desperation of not being able to work. Even his social life has suffered dramtically.
Call that compensation? mad
She is no closer to getting that amount of money than I am for the claim I am about to put in for listening to whinging gits. She is 'claiming'. Nothing more.
Once/if she has been awarded a huge amount we can all get on our high horses and wheeling out 'similar' stories with an unjust ending that shows the depths this country has sunk etc etc. Until then she is as likely to get the 16 mill as I am. rolleyes
Quote by splendid_
She is no closer to getting that amount of money than I am for the claim I am about to put in for listening to whinging gits. She is 'claiming'. Nothing more.
Once/if she has been awarded a huge amount we can all get on our high horses and wheeling out 'similar' stories with an unjust ending that shows the depths this country has sunk etc etc. Until then she is as likely to get the 16 mill as I am. rolleyes

Well here is one story with the same tones as the case going ahead now.

Same card as this new case. You bet they will get the money. The banks do not want to go to court, so will settle...mark my words.
Maybe I should get on my high horse over that scandal then? wink
I think my question has been missed ... I'm not moaning that this woman has made such a claim, moreso that the "size" of the claim seems to be extraordinarily disproportionate to the claim!
Can anyone justify that their feelings were that hurt, that their loss of earnings (when you earn the average wage) etc is so great that it justifies an extortionate claim?
Where does this "go for broke" attitude lead? In claiming such large amounts, are we not opening ourselves up for scorn, rather than claim a relative amount where people would respect the fight more than the claim? Or is that a rose tinted view?
It is more than likely greedy solicitors than put in the claim, for those ammounts.
They are as greedy as the people claiming sometimes.
Quote by kentswingers777
She is no closer to getting that amount of money than I am for the claim I am about to put in for listening to whinging gits. She is 'claiming'. Nothing more.
Once/if she has been awarded a huge amount we can all get on our high horses and wheeling out 'similar' stories with an unjust ending that shows the depths this country has sunk etc etc. Until then she is as likely to get the 16 mill as I am. rolleyes

Well here is one story with the same tones as the case going ahead now.

Same card as this new case. You bet they will get the money. The banks do not want to go to court, so will settle...mark my words.
Maybe I should get on my high horse over that scandal then? wink
These women claimed that they were being racially and sexually abused at work. The company accepted it by settling out of court. Whats the problem?
If the company/employees didn't do it then they should have fought it in court. Since they bottled it then they are guilty. To racially and sexually abuse anyone at work I am glad the company got stuffed by the courts. The amount should be enough to not just compensate the individual but to send out the message that this behaiour will not be tolerated at work/in workplaces
Dave_Notts
Oh dear, oh dear.
On record the company involved were not found guilty at all. They decided to settle to " get rid of it ".
Thats problem with the blame and claim culture now, firms just cannot be bothered to fight it in court. If it is a race row invariably they know that even if they win, people will say no smoke without fire.
Sometimes it is just better to pay up and shut up.
You are being so naive if you think they only settled because they were guilty, how does anyone know until a jury or judge decides so? No wonder we have such a high percentage of claims with people like some around.
I think you'll find they settled out of court to keep them quiet.
But the case was dramatically halted after Tradition agreed an out-of-court settlement in return for the women signing confidentiality clauses.

Obviously they had a good story to tell......
Quote by kentswingers777
Oh dear, oh dear.
On record the company involved were not found guilty at all. They decided to settle to " get rid of it ".
In a criminal court you can plead guilty and be sentenced or plead not guilty and have a full trial. In the civil courts you can "settle out of court" or have a full trial. The company decided after looking at the evidence that they would be found guilty so they opted to admit their guilt before going to court. That is how our justice system works
Thats problem with the blame and claim culture now, firms just cannot be bothered to fight it in court.
For an accident, if the claim is below a £1000 then I would agree with you. Anything above that then the insurance would want to fight it if they believed they had a defence. For the abuse claim, this wouldn't be sorted by the insurance so the company would have to pay it out of their own pockets. So it would be their choice to fight in court. If they didn't fight it then the courts would be inundated with these claims but they are not.
If it is a race row invariably they know that even if they win, people will say no smoke without fire.
Then it does not matter if they win or lose so they should fight it. If they don't then they are putting their hands up and admitting they did do what the claimant said.
Sometimes it is just better to pay up and shut up.
Yep.......when they are guilty. They knew that so they paid up and then shut up the claimants by getting them to sign confidentiality clauses. That speaks a lot more to me than saying it is a race card issue.
You are being so naive if you think they only settled because they were guilty, how does anyone know until a jury or judge decides so?
No naivety here. The justice system is there for the company to clear its name. They chose to accept responsibilty so they chose to accept the guilt. I didn't........they did. Even in a criminal trail, a judge or jury does not have to decide your guilt.......you decide by saying "guilty or not guilty me Lord".
An out of court settlement is made before the end of the trial. So what can happen is the company can hear the trial and see if it is going their way. If it looks like they are going to lose then they will pull out of the trial and "offer out of court". This wastes my money as a tax payer by having to play the company/solicitor games. My view is that if a company elects for court then they have to follow it through to the end.

No wonder we have such a high percentage of claims with people like some around.
The insurance business says that there is no compensation culture.
Compensation culture has usurped political correctness, welfare cheats, single mothers and new age travellers as the right’s new bogeyman-in-chief. According to the Confederation of British Industry (CBI), the Conservative Party and just about every newspaper columnist in Britain, it threatens very soon to bankrupt the country.
That there is no evidence to support such a claim, is, as always, irrelevant. Despite the legalisation in 2000 of “no win, no fee” lawsuits, the total cost of compensation cases in Britain has remained, in real terms, static since 1989.(3) The two biggest claims marketing companies - the great beneficiaries of compensation culture - have both gone bust.(4) Last year the number of accident claims fell by 9.5%.(5) The government’s Better Regulation Task Force, which at other times has taken the part of big business, bluntly reports that “the compensation culture is a myth”.(6)

Dave_Notts
My main gripes in these two cases are.... the ammount of money either paid out or is asked for. Secondly the fact that race is now a massive issue, or religion is used.
Are you really telling me that in this case and the other case I have highlighted that they all suffered " alleged sexual, racial and religious discrimination "? What all three? Normally it is just the one, but no they pick all three. Really! Sorry I just do not buy that crap. In golden Britain today, use race or religion as your weapon of choice, and a lot do, then you are on a winner.
Companies or individuals do not want to be classed as racist, or against any religion. Why would anyone want to go through the court system, where that is the main issue. We all know people can be found guilty, even though later proved innocent.
In the banks cases it is the " companies " money, not their own. For a bank to pay whatever millions it may be, bears no reference to anything. The banks in these cases may or may not have a case to answer, but with the money they have at their disposal, they could have dragged it through the courts for years.
They could have employed the best barristers money can buy. I wonder how these women manged to fund their court cases? I bet it was some organisation that was backing their religous or race grounds? Or had a long drawn out case have happened, who was going to pick up the tab for these women?
The banks settled with no stain on their credibilty, there lies the main reason for not wanting to bother to fight it, plus the fact...well it ain't our money so will just pay out.
I do not think any guilt is laid at their door, just because they did not want any bad publicity, so decided to take the " easy " way out... and settle.
But what a crap ammount of money. As a Insurance company once advertised " where there's blame, there's a claim ". And don't people know that to be the case?
It was an industrial tribunal case.
In such cases mediation is the main route to settling the issue.
The twins were represented by a firm of solicitors, probably no-win-no-fee
But after last-minute talks the women secured a settlement believed to be worth £4million which will stop the full details being made public.
However the Mail can reveal that one of the reasons that lawyers were so keen to thrash out a settlement with the sisters is that they planned to make sordid allegations that executives used prostitutes.
Brokers, they alleged, took clients to Secrets, a lap dancing club on Grays Inn Road, Central London.
The club, which boasts of being where ‘real boys’ from the City ‘come out to play’, charges £10 entrance fee and then £20 for a fully nude private dance.
It promises a ‘magical experience’ with fifty dancers from a wide mix of nationalites dressed in ‘spectacular outfits from long evening dresses, revealing all the right curves, to fabulous sexy lingerie’

So, nothing really new in the high-finance-it's-not-our-money-so-splash-it-around biz ?
All this about "racism" and "religionism", I think it's mainly because a pair of good looking female muslims won loads of dosh from a large organisation that should have better employment policies towards people.
In other words you're pissed because:
They're women ?
They're muslim ?
They're now richer than they were before ?
You just don't think people should have recourse to law because they're common ?
live with it. They had the right to go to law, they exercised that right.
If the case was winnable it would have been fought. It was settled because they did not want the names of those indulgers revealed. If they had been revealed and the "evidence" had been lies one presumes that another civil case would have been started for defamation ?
Draw your own conclusions.
Quote by kentswingers777
My main gripes in these two cases are.... the ammount of money either paid out or is asked for.
I once asked our insurance company why we have £10,000,000 on the public liability. She told me that it would be ok to kill a binman as that would only cost about £500,000 to settle in lost wages if he was 25. However, if we killed a pilot then it would definitely be near the £10,000,000 in compenstaion. That is why the numbers sound rediculous but work out what these women were worth. They earned £50,000 in salary and another £50,000 in bonus. If the money never increased, over a 40 year working life they would earn £4,000,000. What did they get in compensation.......oh £4,000,000.
Secondly the fact that race is now a massive issue, or religion is used.
Only seems to be an issue to those that have never been abused sexually, racially or religiously.
Are you really telling me that in this case and the other case I have highlighted that they all suffered " alleged sexual, racial and religious discrimination "?
Yes
What all three?
Yes
Normally it is just the one, but no they pick all three. Really! Sorry I just do not buy that crap.
So people are not abused at work racially, sexually and religiously at the same time? Does the person doing the bullying stop when they have racially abused them and not do any other type of bullying? A bully is a bully and will lash out at any thing they can. So yes it is possible to have all three at the same time.
In golden Britain today, use race or religion as your weapon of choice, and a lot do, then you are on a winner.
Only if the company are guilty of the accusation will compensation be paid.
Companies or individuals do not want to be classed as racist, or against any religion. Why would anyone want to go through the court system, where that is the main issue. We all know people can be found guilty, even though later proved innocent.
To prove their innocence would have been my first thought. But the example of these two women you use, the company has not been found guilty. They accepted their guilt.
In the banks cases it is the " companies " money, not their own. For a bank to pay whatever millions it may be, bears no reference to anything. The banks in these cases may or may not have a case to answer, but with the money they have at their disposal, they could have dragged it through the courts for years.
That is why the legislation has changed to stop this happening. There is now a time scale that each side has to abide by. Failure to stick by the timescale by the accuser will result in the case being dropped. Failure by the accused will see the case won by default
They could have employed the best barristers money can buy. I wonder how these women manged to fund their court cases?
No win-no fee. This system has been around for decades. People have only seen this when advertising was allowed. Do Civil cases get legal aid? I have no idea on that one.
I bet it was some organisation that was backing their religous or race grounds? Or had a long drawn out case have happened, who was going to pick up the tab for these women?
The company they were fighting against would have picked up the tab if they won and the solicitors representing them would have picked up the tab if they lost.
The banks settled with no stain on their credibilty, there lies the main reason for not wanting to bother to fight it, plus the fact...well it ain't our money so will just pay out.
Yes there is a stain. They were guilty of racial, sexual and religious abuse. They then had to gag the women to stop anything else coming out. This reported widely in the press so their reputation was hit.
I do not think any guilt is laid at their door, just because they did not want any bad publicity, so decided to take the " easy " way out... and settle.
Really? How did you work out that?
But what a crap ammount of money. As a Insurance company once advertised " where there's blame, there's a claim ". And don't people know that to be the case?
And so they should. If people get injured by the negligence of another person or entity then they have the right to a fair compensation............thats why I like this country
Dave_Notts
Quote by JTS
In other words you're pissed because:
They're women ?
They're muslim ?
They're now richer than they were before ?
You just don't think people should have recourse to law because they're common ?

How can you justify those claims?
I try to say my thought process, as does Kenty. We may have ding dongs but we type out why we think a certain way rather than give short posts. Thats why we can both be picked to bits as the posts are so long biggrin
Dave_Notts
So there! lol
Well, when you're exercising your thought processes you may cast an eye on the question mark (?) at the end of each sentence that you quoted above.
The majority of INDUSTRIAL TRIBUNAL cases are settled out of the court process, mediation is COMPULSORY.
ACAS would have been involved in sorting-out an agreement between the parties involved.
Bullying, sexual discrimination (calling a woman a tart, or saying "get 'em out luv", even in fun is definitely a no.... ) are both rife in whatever industry you work. So is jealousy of women who are higher-up the ladder.
The odds are weighted against the claimant in any legal action in this country, and in an employment court a non-disclosure clause is standard. So are clauses stating no further contact with any of the respondents employees etc. Since the figures vary between 4 million to 10 million one can assume that the awarded sum is also subject to non-disclosure. Which means the 'papers are practicing their usual anal speaking. Most awards are in 3 to 4 figures. Since they were paid a high salary the awarded sum would have reflected that salary.
Quote by Dave__Notts
My main gripes in these two cases are.... the ammount of money either paid out or is asked for.
I once asked our insurance company why we have £10,000,000 on the public liability. She told me that it would be ok to kill a binman as that would only cost about £500,000 to settle in lost wages if he was 25. However, if we killed a pilot then it would definitely be near the £10,000,000 in compenstaion. That is why the numbers sound rediculous but work out what these women were worth. They earned £50,000 in salary and another £50,000 in bonus. If the money never increased, over a 40 year working life they would earn £4,000,000. What did they get in compensation.......oh £4,000,000.
Secondly the fact that race is now a massive issue, or religion is used.
Only seems to be an issue to those that have never been abused sexually, racially or religiously.
Are you really telling me that in this case and the other case I have highlighted that they all suffered " alleged sexual, racial and religious discrimination "?
Yes
What all three?
Yes
Normally it is just the one, but no they pick all three. Really! Sorry I just do not buy that crap.
So people are not abused at work racially, sexually and religiously at the same time? Does the person doing the bullying stop when they have racially abused them and not do any other type of bullying? A bully is a bully and will lash out at any thing they can. So yes it is possible to have all three at the same time.
In golden Britain today, use race or religion as your weapon of choice, and a lot do, then you are on a winner.
Only if the company are guilty of the accusation will compensation be paid.
Companies or individuals do not want to be classed as racist, or against any religion. Why would anyone want to go through the court system, where that is the main issue. We all know people can be found guilty, even though later proved innocent.
To prove their innocence would have been my first thought. But the example of these two women you use, the company has not been found guilty. They accepted their guilt.
In the banks cases it is the " companies " money, not their own. For a bank to pay whatever millions it may be, bears no reference to anything. The banks in these cases may or may not have a case to answer, but with the money they have at their disposal, they could have dragged it through the courts for years.
That is why the legislation has changed to stop this happening. There is now a time scale that each side has to abide by. Failure to stick by the timescale by the accuser will result in the case being dropped. Failure by the accused will see the case won by default
They could have employed the best barristers money can buy. I wonder how these women manged to fund their court cases?
No win-no fee. This system has been around for decades. People have only seen this when advertising was allowed. Do Civil cases get legal aid? I have no idea on that one.
I bet it was some organisation that was backing their religous or race grounds? Or had a long drawn out case have happened, who was going to pick up the tab for these women?
The company they were fighting against would have picked up the tab if they won and the solicitors representing them would have picked up the tab if they lost.
The banks settled with no stain on their credibilty, there lies the main reason for not wanting to bother to fight it, plus the fact...well it ain't our money so will just pay out.
Yes there is a stain. They were guilty of racial, sexual and religious abuse. They then had to gag the women to stop anything else coming out. This reported widely in the press so their reputation was hit.
I do not think any guilt is laid at their door, just because they did not want any bad publicity, so decided to take the " easy " way out... and settle.
Really? How did you work out that?
But what a crap ammount of money. As a Insurance company once advertised " where there's blame, there's a claim ". And don't people know that to be the case?
And so they should. If people get injured by the negligence of another person or entity then they have the right to a fair compensation............thats why I like this country
Dave_Notts

FFS Dave, you are getting more like Peanut by the day. wink
Quote by kentswingers777
FFS Dave, you are getting more like Peanut by the day. wink

Bollox lol
He can spell and put things eloquently. I ramble getting to a point. Thats how I understand you lol
Dave_Notts
Quote by Dave__Notts

FFS Dave, you are getting more like Peanut by the day. wink

Bollox lol
He can spell and put things eloquently. I ramble getting to a point. Thats how I understand you lol
Dave_Notts
I dont understand anything you say...its all waffle and bollox really. wink