The idea that one is going to achieve some privacy by not having verification is only slightly useful I think. Getting into adult sexual practices usually exposes one's sex life. As a result 'privacy' is slightly compromised.
To a certain extent one can achieve 'secrecy', but this is often undone when one encounter's a former lover and the body language and tell tale signs soon give the game away. In which case the umbrella one is operating under is quite possibly more characteristic of the behaviours associated with 'cheating'.
I haven't seen a site where people are given negative verifications either on their performance or behaviours. What is out there on record is fairly benign and simply indicates that people do meet and a good time is had by all.
Also if one uses other sites and abides by the format there, and accepts that verification is part of being a member, how can one argue passionately against it on this site?
I can't help thinking it's a legacy issue that has been handed down from the originators. An idea with good intentions but creating repeatable arguments.
The absence of a formal system simply means that people will ask each other for verification about new people. It makes sense as its simply an extention of the principles of safe sex, personal safety and responsibility for one's and other's actions. Why it can't be seen in this positive light is a bit worrying, I think.
I think the theories of how people are going to abuse a system are a bit weak. Seemingly based on the assumption that people are going to be simple enough to treat it like a menu, and work alone in the dark. I don't think people are that dumb.
A list of people allows you to contact other verifiers, which gives you a headstart in making your choice. From them you can get a reasonable idea of a prospective lover and their behaviour etc. If you find there is no response or it sets off alarm bells, you have found it easier to reach your decision. This is what people are going to do in social situations by word of mouth anyway.
Can I just add that this is the most civilised debate we've had on this subject that I can remember.
.