Join the most popular community of UK swingers now
Login

Respect from children and punishments...

last reply
59 replies
1.8k views
0 watchers
0 likes
Quote by mrstyneside4fun
they just little shites between 13 and 16 and no matter what punishment you give them they will find away round it. Ours were like what your going through at the moment but we pleased to say they great now could not ask for better kids so there is light at the end of the tunnle. We thought they were going to grow up to be evil but they never do ..... all you can do is just hang in there and rember to take time for your self,s or you will go nuts.
shaz xxx

Thanks Shaz kiss
Quote by Marya_Northeast
i believe - and have read a little about this - that it all started up in the 60's and 70's when so-called child experts encouraged people not to punish but to understand kids and give them the freedom to express themselves blah blah ...

how right this, I went to my local GP for advice on how to deal with a multitude of things that are going on right now.. you know what happened? I received a leaflet through the post entitled "Parentline.. 'how to make your child smile again'" :shock:
Um and when am I allowed to smile again? dunno
Quote by Calista
However, at the moment they know the minute I raise my voice they move and do whatever it is they should be doing or stop what they shouldn't be.
I often wonder if this is part of society's problem. Kids have to be protected now and part of growing up is lost. Instead they look for kicks elsewhere and it comes out as disobedience and lack of respect.

Yes the raising the voice used to work for me, the "look" used to work. Now nothing is working. I keep thinking maybe I've been too strick, maybe I've been too overprotective and kept her from reality and this is why she's breaking free.. who knows?
I think you've hit a very valid point there Cal xx
Quote by jaymar
i believe - and have read a little about this - that it all started up in the 60's and 70's when so-called child experts encouraged people not to punish but to understand kids and give them the freedom to express themselves blah blah ...

how right this, I went to my local GP for advice on how to deal with a multitude of things that are going on right now.. you know what happened? I received a leaflet through the post entitled "Parentline.. 'how to make your child smile again'" :shock:
Um and when am I allowed to smile again? dunno
Sure we can come to some arrangement :rascal:
i think im the oposite to everyone else here .... my kids r late teens and early twenties and iv had very few problems
they have been bought up in a very lenient household but they know the rules even tho there are very few of them biggrin
they have both had ill health at times and therefore have had time off school whenever i or they thought they needed it and im sure they have had time of when maybe they didnt really need it but im ok with that
they have done well at school and both have jobs they love and they are good at them and they are well thought of
i think they key is the lenient and carefree household with few rules, meals werent at "proper" times and werent always conventional, we did mad things with them and generally had a great time, we listened to and respected their opionions .... we certainly had lots of their friends around who all love it at our house
i grew up in a household where i wasnt allowed an opinion a lot of the time and times lived in fear .... no i wasnt abused or beaten but they were simply strict .... i wanted it to be different for my kids
:D
Quote by Mallock2006
i believe - and have read a little about this - that it all started up in the 60's and 70's when so-called child experts encouraged people not to punish but to understand kids and give them the freedom to express themselves blah blah ...

how right this, I went to my local GP for advice on how to deal with a multitude of things that are going on right now.. you know what happened? I received a leaflet through the post entitled "Parentline.. 'how to make your child smile again'" :shock:
Um and when am I allowed to smile again? dunno
Sure we can come to some arrangement :rascal:
69position confused: :grin:
Quote by danne-gary
i think im the oposite to everyone else here .... my kids r late teens and early twenties and iv had very few problems
they have been bought up in a very lenient household but they know the rules even tho there are very few of them biggrin
they have both had ill health at times and therefore have had time off school whenever i or they thought they needed it and im sure they have had time of when maybe they didnt really need it but im ok with that
they have done well at school and both have jobs they love and they are good at them and they are well thought of
i think they key is the lenient and carefree household with few rules, meals werent at "proper" times and werent always conventional, we did mad things with them and generally had a great time, we listened to and respected their opionions .... we certainly had lots of their friends around who all love it at our house
i grew up in a household where i wasnt allowed an opinion a lot of the time and times lived in fear .... no i wasnt abused or beaten but they were simply strict .... i wanted it to be different for my kids
:D

I wish I'd had parents like you.
Quote by danne-gary
i think im the oposite to everyone else here .... my kids r late teens and early twenties and iv had very few problems
they have been bought up in a very lenient household but they know the rules even tho there are very few of them biggrin
they have both had ill health at times and therefore have had time off school whenever i or they thought they needed it and im sure they have had time of when maybe they didnt really need it but im ok with that
they have done well at school and both have jobs they love and they are good at them and they are well thought of
i think they key is the lenient and carefree household with few rules, meals werent at "proper" times and werent always conventional, we did mad things with them and generally had a great time, we listened to and respected their opionions .... we certainly had lots of their friends around who all love it at our house
i grew up in a household where i wasnt allowed an opinion a lot of the time and times lived in fear .... no i wasnt abused or beaten but they were simply strict .... i wanted it to be different for my kids
:D

I have heard this before. I know of a girl who comes from a household like this. She's allowed free reign of her home, boys sleeping over (she's 25 but this has always been allowed since age of 18). There were no rules or boundaries from the parents and she abs adores them.
But what if it went so wrong? No rules or boundaries could quite well take on the opposite affect. You've been lucky I would say Danne, very lucky. xxx
Quote by jaymar
I have heard this before. I know of a girl who comes from a household like this. She's allowed free reign of her home, boys sleeping over (she's 25 but this has always been allowed since age of 18). There were no rules or boundaries from the parents and she abs adores them.
But what if it went so wrong? No rules or boundaries could quite well take on the opposite affect. You've been lucky I would say Danne, very lucky. xxx

My friend is the middle child of 3 and was brought up in the way you describe. Her older and younger brothers are very respectful of their parents and have done well for themselves.
She was the ultimate wild child - whatever you can think of, she's done and has "amounted to nothing" (if you know what i mean) confused
I suppose it's down to personality - nature rather than nurture? But you don't know any of this when you have kids. You can only do your best and hope for the best, eh?
We have friends who'se kids rule the roost in an incredibly "child focused" home. When their 8yo boy yelled at his mum that she was "A f**king bitch" recently, he was just allowed to get away with it. :shock:
Jay- don't get me started on "parentline" etc. Unfortunately, in "The System," when you try to get help you are always seen as being at fault. They ignore the fact that you have other well adjusted kids (for want of a better phrase) because it doesn't fit their "model."
And a :therethere: for everyone here with problems with their "little darlings."
One thing my mum would never change was that we all sat at the dinner table and eat dinner together.
Sometimes we were allowed kfc on a saturday and watched the proffesinals in front of the telly.
Looking back now, i'm glad my parents brought us up the way they did.
Firm, but fair, and no shortage of love.
Thanks mum and dad.
Quote by army24831203
We have friends who'se kids rule the roost in an incredibly "child focused" home. When their 8yo boy yelled at his mum that she was "A f**king bitch" recently, he was just allowed to get away with it. :shock:
Jay- don't get me started on "parentline" etc. Unfortunately, in "The System," when you try to get help you are always seen as being at fault. They ignore the fact that you have other well adjusted kids (for want of a better phrase) because it doesn't fit their "model."
And a :therethere: for everyone here with problems with their "little darlings."

just seen this post OMG I WOULD BLOW sorry but if thats what is accepted how the hell can you go there. If an adult spoke to me like that i would go mental... A CHILD NOOOO WAY they dont have respect for them selve at all or they would not allow kids to do that. I am glad i havnt got friends like that confused
They're both very well educated too- he has no fewer than three degrees, but I suppose thats beside the point. TBH, the dad is a really good friend of ours- but the mum..... mad Not my bloody fault her husband has a major crush on me!
Actually, the kid was right rotflmao
>>>>>>In no way excusing said child's behaviour<<<<<
I don't know if this helps but - - - I was the youngest of 3 and tended to get into all the trouble. I must have been a total pain - mind you the punishments were there along with respect - but I was still a trial to my Mum. My Dad never helped with the discipline btw.
Well, the point is I ended up as a responsible adult, running own home, responsible job etc so don't fret too much about your teens - they'll turn out alright.
I totally believe that if they have the love, discipline and stability (even one parent) up to 10 or so, they won't go far from the rails in their teens and will eventually come back - so long as they always have the way back open to them.
Oh just rememebred - I did end up as a swinger - maybe I shouldn't claim to be quite so responsible LOL. (At least not respectable)
I think I've been either very lucky with my kids or I'm doing something right, so far I've never had any problems with them. Some friends say I'm too soft but its them thats being called into school to see what their child has done. I have never shouted hit or swore at my kids, thats not to say I wouldn't I just haven't needed too. I have always believed that children take their parents for granted but not their friends so I try to be the best friend to my kids I can and it seems to work. Rather than stop pocket money or take away the platstation I sit them down and ask them what how they think the messy bedroom should be sorted. No matter how tired I am if they need me I will summon the strength from somewhere and I think they appreciate that as they always start with "dad I know your tired but"......
If I had a child with some of the problems described on this thread I don't honestly know how I'd deal with it as I take life pretty much as it comes, all I can say is that my heart goes out to you it must be very difficult trying to be authoritive with one you hold so dear.......
Hugs to all that are dealing with 'little darlings' at the moment and you have my total sympathy. My situation is slightly different but just as frustrating.
I work full time Mon-Sat, the kids' Dad lives 30 miles away and is just here on weekends, so my Dad is the one who does the school run and has my kids until I come home around pm.
Now my kids (son aged 11, daughter aged 9) are no angels, they squabble over the slightest thing-but they know when I raise my voice I mean business and the squabbling stops. I rarely have to punish them, but when I do it's no Wii, no PS2 etc etc. There's no back chat, a little sulking but that's to be expected. However, when my Dad looks after them it's a different story. I have learned (just this evening) that my 'little darlings' have in the past week, swore at my parents, told them they will "do what I want" and referred to my mother as, "the bitch from Hell". To say I am livid is an understatement!
My initial reaction is to stop all privileges and give them a good talking to, but my Dad thinks he should be the one to deal with it as it's him who looks after them while I am in work. I have tried to explain that he's the main problem as he's not consistent in his punishments (he had a hard life growing up and finds it hard to be tough on the kids) but he feels he would be betraying the kids' confidences.
ARRRGGHHH!!
I know if I talk to and punish them things will change. He is insisting that I don't and to let him deal with it (even though he's agreed he's too soft and they are getting too hard to control). So I am stuck between a rock and a hard place. My kids wouldn't dream of behaving with me the way they do with him, but as he's the one who looks after them for me to work, I don't want to cause friction by punishing the kids for bad behaviour I am not supposed to know about.
Any suggestions ?? confused
Quote by BiWelshMinx
Hugs to all that are dealing with 'little darlings' at the moment and you have my total sympathy. My situation is slightly different but just as frustrating.
I work full time Mon-Sat, the kids' Dad lives 30 miles away and is just here on weekends, so my Dad is the one who does the school run and has my kids until I come home around pm.
Now my kids (son aged 11, daughter aged 9) are no angels, they squabble over the slightest thing-but they know when I raise my voice I mean business and the squabbling stops. I rarely have to punish them, but when I do it's no Wii, no PS2 etc etc. There's no back chat, a little sulking but that's to be expected. However, when my Dad looks after them it's a different story. I have learned (just this evening) that my 'little darlings' have in the past week, swore at my parents, told them they will "do what I want" and referred to my mother as, "the bitch from Hell". To say I am livid is an understatement!
My initial reaction is to stop all privileges and give them a good talking to, but my Dad thinks he should be the one to deal with it as it's him who looks after them while I am in work. I have tried to explain that he's the main problem as he's not consistent in his punishments (he had a hard life growing up and finds it hard to be tough on the kids) but he feels he would be betraying the kids' confidences.
ARRRGGHHH!!
I know if I talk to and punish them things will change. He is insisting that I don't and to let him deal with it (even though he's agreed he's too soft and they are getting too hard to control). So I am stuck between a rock and a hard place. My kids wouldn't dream of behaving with me the way they do with him, but as he's the one who looks after them for me to work, I don't want to cause friction by punishing the kids for bad behaviour I am not supposed to know about.
Any suggestions ?? confused

This is a hard one. But when it comes down to it, they are YOUR kids. What you say has to go - that includes the discipline levels when they are with another carer.
Obviously it's very hard to tell you Dad what to do, or go against his wishes, but maybe you can make progress by discussing with him what he will do with them and agreeing his strategy before he does it. With the proviso that if it doesn't work, you then take over.
Perhaps the kids should be made aware - in a general way - that their behaviour away from you will get back to you eventually. It certainly would at school or at formal child-minding situations.
You have to have words Minxy. They're not going to take their Grandad seriously. confused
I think there are some basic rules about dealing with kids. If you wouldn't accept behaviour from an adult you shouldn't accept it from a kid. The kid may not understand what they are trying to do, but you have to assert yourself to show what you will accept.
Sometimes this does not need an explanation. Kids just do things and they don't rationalise why and how. Adults have to use the same language to get the message across.
You may only need to do this once or a few times and then you have to hold your ground and be consistent up until the child's ability to rationalise has developed enough to associate things like illogicality, unfairness, hypocrisy etc. Then you are dealing with an adult.
Doing this tells the child about 'you', because you are just as important as the 'me' in the child. Its usually irrelevant about the circumstances, its just about you, your 'me' and the kid's 'me'.
It may shock you at first. But then you find its quite easy to turn on the theatre to get things back into an even playing field. From there you should be able to work things out.
You can't allow yourself to be so demoralised and undermined that you are no longer any use to the people you love.
Quote by jaymar
i think im the oposite to everyone else here .... my kids r late teens and early twenties and iv had very few problems
they have been bought up in a very lenient household but they know the rules even tho there are very few of them biggrin
they have both had ill health at times and therefore have had time off school whenever i or they thought they needed it and im sure they have had time of when maybe they didnt really need it but im ok with that
they have done well at school and both have jobs they love and they are good at them and they are well thought of
i think they key is the lenient and carefree household with few rules, meals werent at "proper" times and werent always conventional, we did mad things with them and generally had a great time, we listened to and respected their opionions .... we certainly had lots of their friends around who all love it at our house
i grew up in a household where i wasnt allowed an opinion a lot of the time and times lived in fear .... no i wasnt abused or beaten but they were simply strict .... i wanted it to be different for my kids
:D

I have heard this before. I know of a girl who comes from a household like this. She's allowed free reign of her home, boys sleeping over (she's 25 but this has always been allowed since age of 18). There were no rules or boundaries from the parents and she abs adores them.
But what if it went so wrong? No rules or boundaries could quite well take on the opposite affect. You've been lucky I would say Danne, very lucky. xxx
read my post again please :D
i said there are rules but very few of them :D
I'm part of the been there done that brigade as far as teenagers are concerned its small consolation hearing this when your experiencing it in real time. All I can say on a positive note is at the moment you have a dark unattractive crysalis thats one day going to emerge into a beautiful butterfly.
Quote by Marya_Northeast

I have heard this before. I know of a girl who comes from a household like this. She's allowed free reign of her home, boys sleeping over (she's 25 but this has always been allowed since age of 18). There were no rules or boundaries from the parents and she abs adores them.
But what if it went so wrong? No rules or boundaries could quite well take on the opposite affect. You've been lucky I would say Danne, very lucky. xxx

My friend is the middle child of 3 and was brought up in the way you describe. Her older and younger brothers are very respectful of their parents and have done well for themselves.
She was the ultimate wild child - whatever you can think of, she's done and has "amounted to nothing" (if you know what i mean) confused
I suppose it's down to personality - nature rather than nurture? But you don't know any of this when you have kids. You can only do your best and hope for the best, eh?
This is true, you can nuture your child the way you want to but at the end of the day it's their personalities that will win, however strong. Mine is very strong willed, too much x
Quote by varca
ooooohhhhhhh Jaymar, a subject close to my heart.......the thing is these days kids have far too many rights.

absolutely!.. which is fine in some context.. but they take it literally
Sorry to hear you are being put through the mill Mar kiss I can totally empathise with you having a teenager of my own who knows exactly which buttons to push evil I am the worlds worst mother and only care about myself apparently if he doesn't get his own way and any threat of punishment (non smacking as i don''t believe in it but boy can he push me...) for his behaviour is usually met with "I'll call childline" I just hand him the phone and call his bluff.
Recently I have found out the reason for a lot of his bad behaviour and his lack of respect for everyone around him including himself. He is being bullied at school again!!! mad He didn't tell me, other children did and he finally admitted that it had been going on and has been for a long time. We are now taking steps to deal with it officially and I can honestly say that I have seen a change in his attitude and behaviour in the short few days since this all came into the open.
Is it possible that something similar could be going on with your child Mar? Just thinking out loud and hoping to hit on something that may help ease your situation :kiss:
Thanks Varca :therethere: , yes I'd thought of that and this weekend we're getting somewhere, there's been mention of "wanting to fit in", this is going to take time I reckon.
Quote by danne-gary
i think im the oposite to everyone else here .... my kids r late teens and early twenties and iv had very few problems
they have been bought up in a very lenient household but they know the rules even tho there are very few of them biggrin
they have both had ill health at times and therefore have had time off school whenever i or they thought they needed it and im sure they have had time of when maybe they didnt really need it but im ok with that
they have done well at school and both have jobs they love and they are good at them and they are well thought of
i think they key is the lenient and carefree household with few rules, meals werent at "proper" times and werent always conventional, we did mad things with them and generally had a great time, we listened to and respected their opionions .... we certainly had lots of their friends around who all love it at our house
i grew up in a household where i wasnt allowed an opinion a lot of the time and times lived in fear .... no i wasnt abused or beaten but they were simply strict .... i wanted it to be different for my kids
:D

I have heard this before. I know of a girl who comes from a household like this. She's allowed free reign of her home, boys sleeping over (she's 25 but this has always been allowed since age of 18). There were no rules or boundaries from the parents and she abs adores them.
But what if it went so wrong? No rules or boundaries could quite well take on the opposite affect. You've been lucky I would say Danne, very lucky. xxx
read my post again please :D
i said there are rules but very few of them :D
I know I'd seen that but I was talking about my friend having had no rules whatsoever and it actually worked for her.
Quote by duncanlondon
I think there are some basic rules about dealing with kids. If you wouldn't accept behaviour from an adult you shouldn't accept it from a kid. The kid may not understand what they are trying to do, but you have to assert yourself to show what you will accept.
Sometimes this does not need an explanation. Kids just do things and they don't rationalise why and how. Adults have to use the same language to get the message across.
You may only need to do this once or a few times and then you have to hold your ground and be consistent up until the child's ability to rationalise has developed enough to associate things like illogicality, unfairness, hypocrisy etc. Then you are dealing with an adult.
Doing this tells the child about 'you', because you are just as important as the 'me' in the child. Its usually irrelevant about the circumstances, its just about you, your 'me' and the kid's 'me'.
It may shock you at first. But then you find its quite easy to turn on the theatre to get things back into an even playing field. From there you should be able to work things out.
You can't allow yourself to be so demoralised and undermined that you are no longer any use to the people you love.

Thanks for your thoughts Duncan, I've read with interest a few bits here x
Quote by winchwench
We have friends who'se kids rule the roost in an incredibly "child focused" home. When their 8yo boy yelled at his mum that she was "A f**king bitch" recently, he was just allowed to get away with it. :shock:
Jay- don't get me started on "parentline" etc. Unfortunately, in "The System," when you try to get help you are always seen as being at fault. They ignore the fact that you have other well adjusted kids (for want of a better phrase) because it doesn't fit their "model."
And a :therethere: for everyone here with problems with their "little darlings."

don't you and I both know it! :therethere:
Quote by foxylady2209
Hugs to all that are dealing with 'little darlings' at the moment and you have my total sympathy. My situation is slightly different but just as frustrating.
I work full time Mon-Sat, the kids' Dad lives 30 miles away and is just here on weekends, so my Dad is the one who does the school run and has my kids until I come home around pm.
Now my kids (son aged 11, daughter aged 9) are no angels, they squabble over the slightest thing-but they know when I raise my voice I mean business and the squabbling stops. I rarely have to punish them, but when I do it's no Wii, no PS2 etc etc. There's no back chat, a little sulking but that's to be expected. However, when my Dad looks after them it's a different story. I have learned (just this evening) that my 'little darlings' have in the past week, swore at my parents, told them they will "do what I want" and referred to my mother as, "the bitch from Hell". To say I am livid is an understatement!
My initial reaction is to stop all privileges and give them a good talking to, but my Dad thinks he should be the one to deal with it as it's him who looks after them while I am in work. I have tried to explain that he's the main problem as he's not consistent in his punishments (he had a hard life growing up and finds it hard to be tough on the kids) but he feels he would be betraying the kids' confidences.
ARRRGGHHH!!
I know if I talk to and punish them things will change. He is insisting that I don't and to let him deal with it (even though he's agreed he's too soft and they are getting too hard to control). So I am stuck between a rock and a hard place. My kids wouldn't dream of behaving with me the way they do with him, but as he's the one who looks after them for me to work, I don't want to cause friction by punishing the kids for bad behaviour I am not supposed to know about.
Any suggestions ?? confused

This is a hard one. But when it comes down to it, they are YOUR kids. What you say has to go - that includes the discipline levels when they are with another carer.
Obviously it's very hard to tell you Dad what to do, or go against his wishes, but maybe you can make progress by discussing with him what he will do with them and agreeing his strategy before he does it. With the proviso that if it doesn't work, you then take over.
Perhaps the kids should be made aware - in a general way - that their behaviour away from you will get back to you eventually. It certainly would at school or at formal child-minding situations.
OMG, I can't comment, I can't even sort my own out ... yours sounds every bit as bad hun.. :therethere: