Join the most popular community of UK swingers now
Login

Sue or not sue! That is the Quetion!

last reply
19 replies
1.1k views
0 watchers
0 likes
Just started this thread on something that was said in another thread about child minders that got me thinking!
The word sued come up to sued a childminder because their child’s shoe laces were not done up correctly and the child fell over could be a reason to sue.
I will tell you my story!
Should I have sued?
14 years ago I found out that the baby I had been carrying for 8 and a half months was not going to survive. 4 days later I had to give birth to a stillborn baby, the consultant that I was under promised me that I could have any pain relief available and I wouldn’t feel a thing. I asked for an epidural, blood test had to be carried out due to clotting factor that if this was given without which, I could become infertile due to the baby being stillborn. These were sent to pathology for immediate response as I was now in labour. The anesthetist was waiting to carry out the epidural, but the blood tests did not come back. And I went through the whole thing without and pain relief that was promised.
Did I feel let down yes I did!
Did I sue?
No I didn’t!
Who would I have sued?
Pathology for not realising that these results were urgent?
My consultant for promising me one thing and then letting me down, but cried with me when I told him what had happened?
Or the anesthetist that sat outside the door the whole time wanting for the results to come back?
Yes I felt angry at the time and totally let down by them all, but I wasn’t angry at them I was angry more about losing my daughter.
I didn’t want to blame anyone for that as it wasn’t really anybodies fault.
And 14 years later I am still glad I didn’t!
I would say to all, think before you sue!
I think I had a strong case, but money would not have brought back my daughter!
So where someone mentioned about suing over a child tripping over a shoe lace just got my anger going!
But I am fine now!
And this experience I have gained a lot of positives from it, that’s strange but true!
Never wallow in self pity it turns to hate!
Never forget but enjoy life!
I still believe there are more people that try to be their best by others, hopefully I am right, and I have a lot of faith in the human race!
It's sad but we live in a culture now where it's far too easy to blame other people for accidents and there are people who will do what they can to gain financially from accidents. People make mistakes, we shouldn't want financial recompense for each mistake that's made.
a consultant who was treating my child was sued by other parents for his mistakes some of which were very bad
i had the chance to but didnt
mainly because i didnt want to put my child thru the stress and strain of it all as he had suffered enough of that due to the consultant in the first place !!
if id been able to do it without hassle for my child then i certainly would have because he (the consultant) caused untold problems for many children including mine
Sorry to hear of your loss Minx :cry:
NHS evil impossible to sue .. apparently. All doctors stick together I'm afraid. When I was a kid I broke my ankle it was misdiagnosed as a sprain, I was sent home with a bandage. I think at that time my parents attempted legal action but it didn't get very far, doctors reports and all that suggested they were right in their diagnosis but that it later went on to become a fracture?!! :shock: ~ that was 25 years ago so maybe there's room for change in that respect?
As for suing over shoe laces... if the parents had the money I'd say "go right ahead... bring it on" good luck to them (not!)
Sometime suing can be the only answer to highlight a problem say with the NHS for example...but do we really want to turn into the Americans with their attitude on suing?
Quote by Mr-Powers
Sometime suing can be the only answer to highlight a problem say with the NHS for example...but do we really want to turn into the Americans with their attitude on suing?

I wouldnt like to follow anybodies lead, least of all the americans!
I would prefer us to be the leaders! wink
After all nobody is perfect, if we got sued for every mistake we made in life, where would we all be today?
Quote by Whipsnspurs
minx i'm very sorry for your loss. it may be 14 years ago but i know that time doesn't stop it from feeling like yesterday if you talk about it. i think you did the right thing for you and you were very strong to be able to think as you did/do.
Thank you!
Talking over the years has been a great healer!
More people should do it, instead of sueing!
And knowing there are more people out there in the world in a worse position than you helps to put thing into perspective.
You never forget, but life goes on to enjoy.
i do wish people would think about things more before sueing. but unfortnately it's no longer the world we live in. i have to be so careful in the job i do. i train people and their horses. i have to have a crb to work with children (not that i mind that at all coz i have nothing to hide) but sometimes people don't understand what you are telling them to do with their bodies and before i could put my hand on their knee and heel to change their leg position. or should and lower back to change that. now i'm not allowed to do this on a child, who probably understand even less than an adult, because it's now classed as grooming!
How sad is all this, it makes you feel guilty, even when all most of us are trying to do is help.
What a damn shame!
i have to ask people to sign a disclaimer before i can teach them but they can still sue me if they fall off their own horse. my insurance premiums are through the roof and so i have to charge accordingly. it's pants but that is now the world we live in. people are so money orientated that any reason to sue seems to be looked upon as a good thing.
Money is the driving force I believe, I didnt want to earn a pound from the death of my daughter.
How sick is that!
But that is some peoples mentally nowdays, the first oportunity they will pounce.
the thing is though that there are some cases that are paid out on that are stupid. but then there are also cases that should be paid out on but arn't. there is no justice sometimes.

And also totally agree with you here, I am not saying some cases of negligents should be ignored. If somebody has caused long term suffering through sheer negligents or mistake whereby the person can not persue the life that had before, then I agree a case should be bought.
But a child tripping over a shoe lace skipping rope etc while in others care! I totally disagree with.
Quote by jaymar
snippity All doctors stick together I'm afraid. snippity

Thats very true Mar, My dad went into hospital with stomach ache, and was given an unnecessary operation, and then returned to a ward where he was largely abandoned and left to refuse food, during either the surgery or the stay on this ward he caught mrsa.
Unfortunately he was already so weak from having no food (he didnt feel like eating because he was in so much pain, so his food was taken away time and again) the mrsa took a hold and he lapsed into a coma and died 3 weeks after being admitted.
We tried to sue (as minx said, it wouldnt have brought my dad back, but he was only 53 and we felt like we had been robbed of 40 years of his life, and of a husband, dad and grandad) I suppose we wanted some sort of justice.
Despite his blood results showing one of the worst infections ever seen, and comments made by doctors in his notes and various other things, as well as being over looked by an 'independant and impartial' (lol) surgeon we were told that everyone had acted in an exemplary manner and were not to blame in any way.
Cause of death on his certificate still stands as severe septicaemia caused by 2 large duodenal ulcers (the fact that these hadnt burst or bled in order to spread the infection, was somehow omitted)
Doctors all come from the same med schools, country clubs, gentlemans clubs, rugger teams, universities etc and they DO always stick together as its a very closely knit 'old boys' network. They always watch each others backs at every opportunity, as its never known when the favour will need to be reciprocated.
Sorry for the long post, and the hi-jack minx (i find it quite therapeutic to write things down) but i do agree that this is a very litigious society we live in, where people are encouraged to sue for the slightest (and stupidest) little things, and they are the easiest cases to get compensation for.
The people who have really suffered have to fight tooth and nail to get anything, IF they get anything at all.
Quote by Bonedigger
snippity All doctors stick together I'm afraid. snippity

Thats very true Mar, My dad went into hospital with stomach ache, and was given an unnecessary operation, and then returned to a ward where he was largely abandoned and left to refuse food, during either the surgery or the stay on this ward he caught mrsa.
Unfortunately he was already so weak from having no food (he didnt feel like eating because he was in so much pain, so his food was taken away time and again) the mrsa took a hold and he lapsed into a coma and died 3 weeks after being admitted.
We tried to sue (as minx said, it wouldnt have brought my dad back, but he was only 53 and we felt like we had been robbed of 40 years of his life, and of a husband, dad and grandad) I suppose we wanted some sort of justice.
Despite his blood results showing one of the worst infections ever seen, and comments made by doctors in his notes and various other things, as well as being over looked by an 'independant and impartial' (lol) surgeon we were told that everyone had acted in an exemplary manner and were not to blame in any way.
Cause of death on his certificate still stands as severe septicaemia caused by 2 large duodenal ulcers (the fact that these hadnt burst or bled in order to spread the infection, was somehow omitted)
Doctors all come from the same med schools, country clubs, gentlemans clubs, rugger teams, universities etc and they DO always stick together as its a very closely knit 'old boys' network. They always watch each others backs at every opportunity, as its never known when the favour will need to be reciprocated.
Sorry for the long post, and the hi-jack minx (i find it quite therapeutic to write things down) but i do agree that this is a very litigious society we live in, where people are encouraged to sue for the slightest (and stupidest) little things, and they are the easiest cases to get compensation for.
The people who have really suffered have to fight tooth and nail to get anything, IF they get anything at all.
Please dont say sorry! that is no way a hi-jack
I think yours is such an example when I believe there are grounds to sue!
Mine was so different nothing anyone could have done would have saved my daughter!
Your Dad is totally diferent as I see it and it has made a lasting impact on lots of peoples lives, and with him being so young!
Talking I know is a great therapy and thanks for telling us your story.
minx xxx
Quote by Bonedigger
snippity All doctors stick together I'm afraid. snippity

Thats very true Mar, My dad went into hospital with stomach ache, and was given an unnecessary operation, and then returned to a ward where he was largely abandoned and left to refuse food, during either the surgery or the stay on this ward he caught mrsa.
Unfortunately he was already so weak from having no food (he didnt feel like eating because he was in so much pain, so his food was taken away time and again) the mrsa took a hold and he lapsed into a coma and died 3 weeks after being admitted.
We tried to sue (as minx said, it wouldnt have brought my dad back, but he was only 53 and we felt like we had been robbed of 40 years of his life, and of a husband, dad and grandad) I suppose we wanted some sort of justice.
Despite his blood results showing one of the worst infections ever seen, and comments made by doctors in his notes and various other things, as well as being over looked by an 'independant and impartial' (lol) surgeon we were told that everyone had acted in an exemplary manner and were not to blame in any way.
Cause of death on his certificate still stands as severe septicaemia caused by 2 large duodenal ulcers (the fact that these hadnt burst or bled in order to spread the infection, was somehow omitted)
Doctors all come from the same med schools, country clubs, gentlemans clubs, rugger teams, universities etc and they DO always stick together as its a very closely knit 'old boys' network. They always watch each others backs at every opportunity, as its never known when the favour will need to be reciprocated.
Sorry for the long post, and the hi-jack minx (i find it quite therapeutic to write things down) but i do agree that this is a very litigious society we live in, where people are encouraged to sue for the slightest (and stupidest) little things, and they are the easiest cases to get compensation for.
The people who have really suffered have to fight tooth and nail to get anything, IF they get anything at all.
kiss similar thing happened to my friend's dad.
Thanks mar and minx xxxxxxx kiss
Just to clarify, it was me who mentioned sueing in another thread.
Unfortunately we live in an age of litigation and it is highly possibly someone would sue because their child, in their eyes, wasnt being cared for properly.
Im sorry to hear about your loss 'Minx' and I think most of us will have stories to tell, myself included.
I was given the wrong blood during a transfusion. All my veins had collapsed and there was a problem finding a site to administer an antidote. I remember hearing one of the nursing staff asking who was my next of kin. I was THAT close to death.
Did I sue, no. However, my family said they would have, should I have died.
Mistakes happen but no amount of money can bring back a loved one.
Just to clarify, it was me who mentioned sueing in another thread.
Unfortunately we live in an age of litigation and it is highly possibly someone would sue because their child, in their eyes, wasnt being cared for properly.

I know we are, how sad is that!
What I am asking in such case where a child slips over a skipping rope supplied by the school or children minder or a shoe lace that haden't been tied correctly by a child minder or teacher, causing the child to have an accident.
Should we the parents have a right to sue?
I am talking about a short term injury, not a life threating act through negligents which is something totally different.
Quote by Theladyisaminx
I know we are, how sad is that!
What I am asking in such case where a child slips over a skipping rope supplied by the school or children minder or a shoe lace that haden't been tied correctly by a child minder or teacher, causing the child to have an accident.
Should we the parents have a right to sue?
I am talking about a short term injury, not a life threating act through negligents which is something totally different.

Everyone has the right to litigation.
What if the a child tripped on its shoe laces and hit its head and was left with a brain injury??
No one can tell how an accident is going to turn out, Health and safety practices are there to PREVENT an accident in the 1st place. I would hope if any of my children had to go to a child minder that the childminder had the common sense to check that laces were tied. Are you saying you never ever checked your kids laces were tied properly to prevent even the smallest of trips and tumbles???
Each incident/accident is different. All we can ask is that common sense prevail and if someone hasnt got that common sense then they are well n truly bolloxed!
Sorry to hear about your loss minx ... I absolutely agree with your sentiment though.
Nearly 22 years ago, I went into labour at full term with my 3rd child. I was booked into a local maternity unit with no emergency facilities as I had been through labour successfully twice already. However, the baby was showing signs of distress and so an ambulance was called to transfer us the 15 miles off the peninsula to the nearest emergency maternity hospital.
The message to the ambulance was obviously confused though as they were under the impression it was just a routine transfer and the ambulance took half an hour to arrive from the station just 2 miles away. The delay meant I gave birth on the hard shoulder of the motorway where my son died from being strangled on the cord (the reason for his distress).
The experience was harrowing and I guess I could have sued for the cock up but I just didn't want to. What would we have done with the money? A trip to Disneyland? A new car? It would have felt like blood money and I just couldn't do it.
There are definitely cases for sueing ... especially for the loss of an main breadwinner because of the financial implications but there are also cases where the exchange of money for a life just isn't appropriate. Far better that hard lessons should be learned, taken on board and steps taken to prevent similar tragedies from happenening again.
Quote by Sugar-n-pom
Sorry to hear about your loss minx ... I absolutely agree with your sentiment though.
Nearly 22 years ago, I went into labour at full term with my 3rd child. I was booked into a local maternity unit with no emergency facilities as I had been through labour successfully twice already. However, the baby was showing signs of distress and so an ambulance was called to transfer us the 15 miles off the peninsula to the nearest emergency maternity hospital.
The message to the ambulance was obviously confused though as they were under the impression it was just a routine transfer and the ambulance took half an hour to arrive from the station just 2 miles away. The delay meant I gave birth on the hard shoulder of the motorway where my son died from being strangled on the cord (the reason for his distress).
The experience was harrowing and I guess I could have sued for the cock up but I just didn't want to. What would we have done with the money? A trip to Disneyland? A new car? It would have felt like blood money and I just couldn't do it.
There are definitely cases for sueing ... especially for the loss of an main breadwinner because of the financial implications but there are also cases where the exchange of money for a life just isn't appropriate. Far better that hard lessons should be learned, taken on board and steps taken to prevent similar tragedies from happenening again.

Hi Sugar-n-pom,
I am so sorry to hear about your loss and thanks for sharing it with us. I totally agree with your thoughts to, its good to talk and let others know, there are things that go wrong in life.
But do we all sue, no we just get on with it, and time is a great healer. But we never forget!
I couldnt believe some paople would sue over a child tripping over a shoe lace, hence the thread.
I do believe there are cases when to sue, but others I feel are just ways to earn an easy buck.
No wonder all our insurance premiums have risen so much over the years!
Quote by jaymar
NHS evil impossible to sue .. apparently. All doctors stick together I'm afraid.

Your not kidding...
Called the doctor to my dad as he was suffering pain in the chest and felt sick....
Doctor arrived promptly....
Checked him over and said he had indigestion and gave him a tonic...
1 hour later he was dead after suffering a massive heart attack.....
Tried the formal complaint,disciplanary(sp?) procedure and after 2 1/2 yrs got absolutely nowhere...
Quote by Theladyisaminx
What I am asking in such case where a child slips over a skipping rope supplied by the school or children minder or a shoe lace that haden't been tied correctly by a child minder or teacher, causing the child to have an accident.
Should we the parents have a right to sue?
I am talking about a short term injury, not a life threating act through negligents which is something totally different.

The right to sue needs to be there for occasions when an injury happens because of negligence, but I agree that we are following the septics in becoming a 'sue at the slightest opportunity' culture.
All that will happen is that anyone providing a service will have to take out insurance cover to protect themselves. This will drive prices for those services up and take them out of the reach of some people. Common sense isn't that common unfortunately and seems to be getting less common by the day.
Quote by Theladyisaminx
Just started this thread on something that was said in another thread about child minders that got me thinking!
The word sued come up to sued a childminder because their child’s shoe laces were not done up correctly and the child fell over could be a reason to sue.
I will tell you my story!
Should I have sued?
14 years ago I found out that the baby I had been carrying for 8 and a half months was not going to survive. 4 days later I had to give birth to a stillborn baby, the consultant that I was under promised me that I could have any pain relief available and I wouldn’t feel a thing. I asked for an epidural, blood test had to be carried out due to clotting factor that if this was given without which, I could become infertile due to the baby being stillborn. These were sent to pathology for immediate response as I was now in labour. The anesthetist was waiting to carry out the epidural, but the blood tests did not come back. And I went through the whole thing without and pain relief that was promised.
Did I feel let down yes I did!
Did I sue?
No I didn’t!
Who would I have sued?
Pathology for not realising that these results were urgent?
My consultant for promising me one thing and then letting me down, but cried with me when I told him what had happened?
Or the anesthetist that sat outside the door the whole time wanting for the results to come back?
Yes I felt angry at the time and totally let down by them all, but I wasn’t angry at them I was angry more about losing my daughter.
I didn’t want to blame anyone for that as it wasn’t really anybodies 14 years later I am still glad I didn’t!
I would say to all, think before you sue!
I think I had a strong case, but money would not have brought back my daughter!
So where someone mentioned about suing over a child tripping over a shoe lace just got my anger going!
But I am fine now!
And this experience I have gained a lot of positives from it, that’s strange but true!
Never wallow in self pity it turns to hate!
Never forget but enjoy life!
I still believe there are more people that try to be their best by others, hopefully I am right, and I have a lot of faith in the human race!

There lies a problem Minxy. Sometimes it is nobodys fault just a collection of errors.
There are two thoughts on this thread an accident and negligence. There is a huge difference between the two.
An accident : An unfortunate incident that happens unexpectedly and unintentionally!
Negligence: lack of proper care and attention. Law breach of a duty of care which results in damage.
Where an accident has occured I feel that the right to sue should not happen. Accidents happen all the time through nobodys particular fault. Negligence is another matter completly. If somebody is negligent and proved to be so, then the full force of both the law and the right to sue should be used.
We now have copied the Americans with our claim culture. Doctors must be terrified of doing anything wrong because if they do the health trust could end up paying millions. Or a teacher that takes kids on a school trip, and a child has an " accident ". I would not put myself down for that risk if I was a teacher.
I was told a saying a while back which is so true today in this countries outlook, " where there's blame, there's a claim ". You cannot cover every eventuality in life as far as accidents go, they happen. But negligence should be punished.