Just started this thread on something that was said in another thread about child minders that got me thinking!
The word sued come up to sued a childminder because their child’s shoe laces were not done up correctly and the child fell over could be a reason to sue.
I will tell you my story!
Should I have sued?
14 years ago I found out that the baby I had been carrying for 8 and a half months was not going to survive. 4 days later I had to give birth to a stillborn baby, the consultant that I was under promised me that I could have any pain relief available and I wouldn’t feel a thing. I asked for an epidural, blood test had to be carried out due to clotting factor that if this was given without which, I could become infertile due to the baby being stillborn. These were sent to pathology for immediate response as I was now in labour. The anesthetist was waiting to carry out the epidural, but the blood tests did not come back. And I went through the whole thing without and pain relief that was promised.
Did I feel let down yes I did!
Did I sue?
No I didn’t!
Who would I have sued?
Pathology for not realising that these results were urgent?
My consultant for promising me one thing and then letting me down, but cried with me when I told him what had happened?
Or the anesthetist that sat outside the door the whole time wanting for the results to come back?
Yes I felt angry at the time and totally let down by them all, but I wasn’t angry at them I was angry more about losing my daughter.
I didn’t want to blame anyone for that as it wasn’t really anybodies fault.
And 14 years later I am still glad I didn’t!
I would say to all, think before you sue!
I think I had a strong case, but money would not have brought back my daughter!
So where someone mentioned about suing over a child tripping over a shoe lace just got my anger going!
But I am fine now!
And this experience I have gained a lot of positives from it, that’s strange but true!
Never wallow in self pity it turns to hate!
Never forget but enjoy life!
I still believe there are more people that try to be their best by others, hopefully I am right, and I have a lot of faith in the human race!
It's sad but we live in a culture now where it's far too easy to blame other people for accidents and there are people who will do what they can to gain financially from accidents. People make mistakes, we shouldn't want financial recompense for each mistake that's made.
a consultant who was treating my child was sued by other parents for his mistakes some of which were very bad
i had the chance to but didnt
mainly because i didnt want to put my child thru the stress and strain of it all as he had suffered enough of that due to the consultant in the first place !!
if id been able to do it without hassle for my child then i certainly would have because he (the consultant) caused untold problems for many children including mine
Sometime suing can be the only answer to highlight a problem say with the NHS for example...but do we really want to turn into the Americans with their attitude on suing?
Just to clarify, it was me who mentioned sueing in another thread.
Unfortunately we live in an age of litigation and it is highly possibly someone would sue because their child, in their eyes, wasnt being cared for properly.
Im sorry to hear about your loss 'Minx' and I think most of us will have stories to tell, myself included.
I was given the wrong blood during a transfusion. All my veins had collapsed and there was a problem finding a site to administer an antidote. I remember hearing one of the nursing staff asking who was my next of kin. I was THAT close to death.
Did I sue, no. However, my family said they would have, should I have died.
Mistakes happen but no amount of money can bring back a loved one.
Sorry to hear about your loss minx ... I absolutely agree with your sentiment though.
Nearly 22 years ago, I went into labour at full term with my 3rd child. I was booked into a local maternity unit with no emergency facilities as I had been through labour successfully twice already. However, the baby was showing signs of distress and so an ambulance was called to transfer us the 15 miles off the peninsula to the nearest emergency maternity hospital.
The message to the ambulance was obviously confused though as they were under the impression it was just a routine transfer and the ambulance took half an hour to arrive from the station just 2 miles away. The delay meant I gave birth on the hard shoulder of the motorway where my son died from being strangled on the cord (the reason for his distress).
The experience was harrowing and I guess I could have sued for the cock up but I just didn't want to. What would we have done with the money? A trip to Disneyland? A new car? It would have felt like blood money and I just couldn't do it.
There are definitely cases for sueing ... especially for the loss of an main breadwinner because of the financial implications but there are also cases where the exchange of money for a life just isn't appropriate. Far better that hard lessons should be learned, taken on board and steps taken to prevent similar tragedies from happenening again.