Join the most popular community of UK swingers now
Login

The SH Philosophy/Discussion Forum

last reply
12 replies
880 views
0 watchers
0 likes
I have a humble suggestion for Mark that I would like to run past the rest of you as well first. Should we have a new section to the Forum? It's purpose being for the more long-winded and thoughtful threads that discuss topics relevant to the swinging scene.
I have noticed that the Cafe moves a lot faster now than it did 3 or 4 months ago, which I think is a good thing as it shows a lot of people are coming on here and getting involved. However there have been quite a few interesting threads on various aspects of swinging. (Bi-sexualality, Polyamory, Married men, Condoms etc.) These threads slip down the page very quickly and anyone who doesn't come in every day or who wnats to think carefully before they post their opinions on them is likely to miss them or feel that there is no interest so why bother posting.
If these threads where in a seperate Forum they would stay current for much longer and act as a resource of information and opinion for new people joining the site.
So having stuck my neck out and rambled on as usual what do the rest of you think?
Roger.
That is a good point Roger but I personnally think splitting the message boards would be a bad thing.
What happens if you get the usual, why doesn't swinging work from the less informed newbies over and over again in the new swinging board? People will still want to post their adverts in there because it is another board and it looks like it would be more work for the overworked and undersexed (due to work load) mods on here.
I think we tried to have a sticky at the top of the page that pointed to the various threads that have already been done and pretty much exhausted. These would be a point of reference. But how often does somebody read through such long threads and jsut come to the conclusion that their opinion deserves their own answer.
To me it looks like swings and round-a-bouts. Change = Bad as any technician would tell you.
yeah matt i think so!
roger i like the idea in principle, and completely take your point! but it's only useful if you actually take time to look about and read stuff.
threads are tumbling off the page at a rapid rate of knots lately, true, cos it is soooooooooooo busy, which as you say is damn good, cos we have more opinions, if you're interested at all in what those opinions are. but many a piece of good advice won't get read regardless! there is already good advice all over the place, that still doesn't get read!
having the odd serious thread in among all the bollox, is probably for the best! and i wouldn't really like to see more forums here ((( fora??? ))) cos it's easy to find the deep stuff right here while you do the bollox thing, and i always know exactly where to come to find it! if it's that good, it may become stickied or moved to the advice sections anyway. very much IMHO.
neil x x x ;-)
Threads that start off light-hearted can digress into a more serious discussion, and vice versa. That's the way normal conversation evolves, and I think having a forum specifically for serious issues would detract from that. You wouldn't get the free flow that you have now - people would be disinclined to add either a humourous comment in the serious forum or something deep and meaningful in the Cafe. Complaints of "off-topic" and "hijack" would increase, threads would be split, moved, and generally buggered about with.
In my opinion, philosophical discussions have a place on this site, and I think the Cafe is precisely the right place for them. I think if we start creating separate forums beyond what we already have, we'll end up over-specialising and have a plethora of single-issue sections and look like every other discussion board around. I think that type of "topification" is great - just not here. biggrin
Ice
IIRC Mark has already thought of this idea when he developed the site and dismissed it because he felt that sectioning it would just detract from the diversity of it.
He'd been on other sites where there were stringent rules about what you could and couldn't post in certain sections and didn't want to restrict this site anywhere near as much.
I know in the past I have been the one arguing for change, but in this case I think if it ain't broke then don't try to fix it.
Quote by easy
but in this case I think if it ain't broke then don't try to fix it.

I agree with what he said!!!
Early poll results, ask the audience or what? Pretty decisive.
Roger (the dragon),
I'd like to send you a message of support here!
One of the reasons the threads move off the page quicker is because people are using the cafe as a place to turn up and say things like "Hey look! I've got ten toes!" or "My hamster ate Freddie Starr this morning" - and while it's funny, and interesting discussions can come out of that sort of thread, it does make some of the more serious threads or, in fact, threads actually about swinging (which I like to follow) drop off to other pages, and as a person who is trying not to lose his job by looking at the 'net too much, it'd be nice if there was a way of going straight to them without running around (yes, I know I could bookmark them, but if I get caught with these sort of bookmarks, I know what's going to happen to me!)
My opinion is that if it's not actually related to swinging, maybe it could stay in the cafe, and if it's related to swinging, it could go to another forum called something like 'Swinging topics' or something like that...
Just my couple of p-worth!
The majority has spoken,and i agree with them
Firstly thank you to everyone who has voted and posted so far - It looks like the forum have made their collective opinion very clear, which is exactly what I was hoping for.
I enjoy the trivial threads just as much as the more serious ones, my point was simply that the more serious threads require more thought about a response. (And at the rate that I think will usually be on page 3 before I reply redface )
I see the point about marginalizing the serious threads (Have seen this happen on another site), and if no-one goes and looks there is no point having them in a seperate place. Also I understand the point about more work for the mods etc.
It looks like I will have to admit defeat gracefully, Thank you for the support Phil_osopher :cheers: , it looks like we are in a minority though. lol Even my wife voted for leaving things as they are. rotflmao rotflmao but then she says I talk and think too much anyway. redface redface
That said I will continue to resurrect threads that I think are interesting, and post long and boring responses to people innocent enquiry's. :twisted: :twisted: :twisted:
Long live Swinging Heaven, the best swinging site in the UK by far in my far from humble opinion. :twisted:
Roger.
Quote by rogerthedragon
That said I will continue to resurrect threads that I think are interesting, and post long and boring responses to people innocent enquiry's. :twisted: :twisted: :twisted:
Long live Swinging Heaven, the best swinging site in the UK by far in my far from humble opinion. :twisted:
Roger.

excellent. I think that maybe some threads need resurrecting from time to time as the people find and leave this site. there's always room for a good debate (as this thread has shown).
If a response is valid then it can't be long and boring (and I'm sure your wife's going to kill me for that lol ).
Nice to have something serious between the bollox (that's a double entendra if I ever heard one).
Quote by easy
Nice to have something serious between the bollox.

I'm nervous enough about shaving as it is, without you going and saying things like that :shock: