Join the most popular community of UK swingers now
Login

women and violence!

last reply
6 replies
740 views
0 watchers
0 likes
The law provides that you are allowed to use *reasonable* force in order to protect yourself or another from crime. The fact that you were defending a woman is not an issue. What is the issue here is that beating the guy up may well be considered unreasonable force, and that is what the law will argue unless you had simply no other option. They will argue that you could have protected yourself, the woman, and your property by making him leave (if possible) and/or calling the police. Taking the law into your own hands in a violent way is not considered justified, usually.
Having said that, I'm not saying that what you did isn't what the guy deserved, just that the law is within its rights not to see it that way.
Badmouthing the magestrate will just get you banged up. Period.
When you say he started on her, I assume you mean violently. If that is the case I would say you were right to step in.
I guess the police would take a view as to whether your actions were excessive or in proportion to what was required to protect her.
Very difficult to form a point of view without knowing all the facts.
Quote by manofmuchfun
I think the magistrate is going to get a mouthfull from me for this charge to come to court...
come on please forum.....your opinions please ?

Does that say anything about your general demeanour in life? Perfect way to get a contempt of court charge.
Once upon a time I was 18 or 19, I was at a friends house when a drunken ex boyfriend of hers came a calling, she answered the door and he essentially forced his way in and wouldn’t leave. She called the police and I positioned myself between him and her, she was pregnant with his child at the time and he was getting abusive and threatening violence, he attempted to headbut me, but was too drunk to land it, I punched him and broke his nose and managed to get him out of the house. The police arrived, he still refused to leave and was arrested. I phoned the local station and said that I was concerned about getting an assault charge; they told me that this was unlikely as the other guy was generally abusive and if he suggested it they would have attempted to dissuade him. I heard nothing more of it.
I think if you are an aggressive character and start spouting the way you suggest you will then you are asking for problems, if you co-operate and are generally understanding and polite then you will be less likely to get done, in my opinion.
Hope that helps.
Chris
Personally my view is he got what he deserved but ..... stepping in and adding violence to an already existent violent relationship is like pouring oil on a fire.
The best course of action in this situation would have been to put the female in touch with one of the support agencies dealing with domestic violence. They are experienced and can give her vital information about restraining orders, building up her confidence, even advice about rehousing etc if she feels she is in danger.
The last thing any violently abused person needs to be near is someone who shows they can be violent too.
I'm not saying I disagree with what you did but there are much better ways to help someone.
I'm locking this because it's a legal matter and while I can see where you are coming from we won't condone violence on the forums.
Jas
XXX