A much discussed subject but one that can cause a change in peoples opinion quite quickly as the EU itself changes.
I know little about EU membership when you take into account the whole spectrum of what membership means to the United Kingdom.
So, what do you think, help me and perhaps others learn.
What are the advantages of being in the EU in 2013 ?
I remember when it was first announced it was all about free trade the ability to move goods easily to any Country within the EU.
It was about being able to work in EU countries without big restrictions
It was about a Market place where the combined powers of Europe could compete against the likes of the USA, China, Japan and Asia, where cheap labour and vast resources were looking to corner the market with cheap grain, cheap electronics, cheap cars, ships, steel, coal and other much needed resources.
Do we still have that problem, are not many of those Countries not now building thier car factories in Britain, are we finding that the workers coming here are far outweighing the benefits of us being able to work abroad, are sub-standard products being dumped in Britain under the ease of trade laws ?
Is our benefits system working against us ?
Are we under too many restrictions from the EU parliament and no longer able to run our own affairs.
Have our contributions to the EU become too much especially in comparison to other member states.
Have we lost too much of our Nationality simply becoming the state of the United Kingdom and not a Country in our own right,
Will things improve in the EU or are we going to be bailing out more and more member states in the near future.
What would be the downsides of leaving the EU
Could we be like Switzerland that isn't an EU member state (and is one of the richest countries in the world) and stand alone perhaps like the Swiss making limited concessions and obtaining limited benefits from the EU (your medical card (the old E111 is acceptable there for example)
Would the remaining EU member states refuse to trade with us and refuse our exports and refuse to sell us thier cars and other products (Switzerland has a healthy trade situation with EU states but can still control how it works unlike us who have to accept the trading rules of the EU)
Will travel to EU states become much more difficult or will they still welcome our tourists and business travellers through need.
SHOULD WE STAY OR SHOULD WE GO ?
This could be a very interesting debate and I believe that if people give thier honest opinions I am about to learn a lot.
And for the record, at this moment I believe we should get out now or use the fact that we are willing to get out as a wedge to get us a fairer deal, but you may change my mind on that if the arguments to maintain the status quo are compelling enough.
Without a Google Mids I am struggling to think of anything good for the Uk being in Europe.
Yes we trade openly with Europe but we have done that since the 70's, when we joined the EEC.
There seem to be many bad points being attached more closely to Europe. Freedom for any single European to come to the UK, on a open border policy. To be honest Mids later this year I cannot see many UK residents going to Bulgaria or Romania but plenty will flock here, as even Cameron has hinted that he does not want others to come here and abuse our welfare and NHS.
We are guided like all the other Euro zone countries to be guided by Europe on all kinds of things, one of them being Human Rights laws, and the inability to deport known terrorists to other countries without Europe's say so. Look at the recent cases.
The money we spend on being a partner in Europe from where I am sitting, we are not getting value for money. As I have stated already Mids, I struggle to find many positive things from being in the European Union. If being a member in Europe allowed us to act upon our own laws, not have Europe interfering at what seems like every case that our Appeal court chucks out and then the European court then goes against us, when we spend billions every year on entry and for very little in return. Where would we be now Mids had we been in the Euro? All those experts in the Houses of Parliament saying we would be left behind in Europe if we did not change to the European money system. Where are those people now Mids, now that the Euro is all but finished and has certainly played a big part in putting other countries like Greece in a financial nightmare. Where are those people Mids?
Can anyone here tell me what this country actually gets back from Europe from the billions we put in?
Is our democratically elected Parliament allowed to act upon it's own laws in the UK? Are we run from Brussels on so many levels? Is Europe a powerhouse of Germans and French railroading the rest into submission?
Is Europe worth being in and the money we spend on it? I do not think it is worth 20% of what it costs us to be honest.
Certainly partial agreement and thankfully some non-agreement, but this I think is a first for the total agreement.
And in the words of Big Brother fans GET BRITAIN OUT! GET BRITAIN OUT! GET BRITAIN OUT!
AND
If Scotland does vote to leave the United Kingdom will they have to apply for EU membership as a Nation in thier own right, would they be allowed to be an EU state, would they be swapping membership of one Group of Nations for another, would they want to join ?
According to an article in the Times today the foreign owned car plants currently operating in the UK sell four out of five cars into Europe giving Nissan and others a competitive edge. If they were to export from Japan every car would have an import duty levied. If Britain is out of the EU and that trading benefit is lost would there be a reason or need to maintain UK car plants when production could be switched to an EU country. Not sure how many people are now employed by foreign owned car manufacturers in the UK but any withdrawal from Europe would be a concern to them.
Not quite the rabid UKIP / Nationalist story normally peddled in the media and for that reason probably ignored by those with. "the agenda."
Yes not being members of the EU could mean our exports incur import duties when arriving in other countries but and therefore make products originating in the UK more expensive, but a £12 Billion cost cut may be able to help out there by making it cheaper for companies to remain in the UK or come to the UK and as I said import tax works both ways, long gone are the days when the UK worried about balancing exports and imports and theses days we do import far more than we export.
Give the revenue we would get but currently dont from import tax in a tax reduction to companies exporting to EU countries to compensate them, use some of it to maintain current prices of goods imported that would go up in price because of the import tax we set.
Countries in the EU will know that and they would have to be reasonable with thier import tax rates or incur higher costs for exporting thier goods to the UK, add to the EU contributions saved the amount we would save in benefits being paid to EU subjects for example the 40,0000 children living in Poland and recieving child benefit would instantly lose that benefit, every EU member currently living in the UK and those wishing to do so would have to apply for work visas and visas to be here, many are an asset and these should be granted but many "do nothing for us" and should go somewhere else.
It would ease the housing problem, perhaps create more jobs (by freeing up jobs where we believe we could fill them with those authorised to live in the UK.
I don't know all the answers but there are areas that can be looked into without it being a "cant do that because" scenario.
Unfortunately any exit from the EU by the UK will be acrimoneous and spiteful. Our major manufacturing industries are not UK owned and the biggest are not reliant on the UK market but the European market. An inability to trade competitively with Europe will result in catastrophic redundancies in the very biggest companies, as well as the smallest. Foreign corporate owners would hold no empathy for employees who voted themselves out of a competitive market place.
Believe it or not most EU citizens (if not the Politicians) can see that the EU is in need of reform because it is not working in one way or another (and for different reasons) for them. Reform is essential and support for this will come from Germany and the greatest opposition from France.
The modern world is a global world made of large trading and military alliances. There is not a single cogent reason why the UK should quite Europe even now, let alone after a revamped EU. The world has changed and we are neither big enough, nor bright enough to punch our way alone in the world. The only people who can't see that are the small minded little englanders who still think we are better and bigger than everyone else and who are living on past glories. For good, or for bad, our future is dependant on modern alliances not on nostalgia. Our capital city is now 45% white, ethnic British so let's get with the modern world - get stuck into revamping Europe, change it and make it work for everyone.
If we were outside the EU ,,,,We would be like a corner shop trying to compete with Tesco !!Reform may indeed be required.....but europe as a trading block can negotiate so much better deals with other countries such as USA and Pacific Rim block. USA has already warned us about pulling out from Europe. This is why the gamble by David Cameron is so scarey. To pull away from Europe would leave us isolated and totally vunerable.
Rather regrettably it simply shows the ignorance of the people who were polled and illustrates how the media controls society at large - just ask Josef Goebbels.
Reminds of Turkeys voting for Christmas as they were promised to get out of the pen.
As a matter of interest this link from the same newspaper has a slightly different slant on the blame for all our troubles:
Do you think we will actually get a referendum on it, first those promising it have to retain the power to implement it, then they have to want to implement it and not just be using the promise of a referendum on something or a change of something to gain votes before an election then coming up with a reason why they cant do it when they reaped the benefits of saying it.
bloody hell TO HOT...talk about turkeys voting for xmas......if you are urgeing people to vote conservative and want to stay inside europe...is that not what you are doing.
Just two comments above you say, you fear that if we had a vote the people would vote us out of Europe and it would be such a dark day that you would up and leave. You also point out Labour and the LibDems won't have a vote, and so therfore we stay in Europe, even if it is be de-fault.
People would know voting for UKIP in a general election would be a sheer waste. So you are clearly saying vote Conservative to get a referendum and to get out of europe !!
I have to say once presented with the stark facts of the matter, it will be a bloody close run thing, and we will stay in by skin of our teeth. however I think it is a very dangerous game of russian roulette that David Cameron is playing, and it could just as easily come back to shoot him straight in the foot !!!
Sorry Dean, but it's not as clear cut as re-elect conservative and vote on whether to stay in Europe. Your forgetting the hidden clause, just like so many others.
nope I dont see it ..... who is offering me what ?